Saw this posted by “war and peas” on mastodon.
this reminded me to close my etsy account. I hope AI bankrupts them.
Any open, federated alternative to Etsy?
Someone linked this place in another thread: https://artisans.coop/
Looks promising as an Etsy alternative if it gets more sellers.

I used to have an Etsy shop selling handmade fine silver chains, but I closed it when they let drop shippers ruin it. And now it’s full of ai slop that doesn’t actually exist. Then when people order it they get plastic junk that vaguely resembles the slop. It pushes legitimate sellers way down the rankings, and tanks their sales.
It happened every time I had a product start to do well. My photos would get downloaded or put through an ai and a bunch of fake listings with the same tags would appear. And they pay to have it at the top of the search results which I couldn’t afford to do. Letting them scrape your photos is the tip of the ice berg when it comes to issues with Etsy.
There was even a whole thing with tons of posts on Reddit a couple years ago with geode mugs.


Was there a time when geode mugs were real? Before AI slop & dropshippers ruined them?
We had so many dreams for the internet, and now this is what it has become.
The allure and convenience of these kinds of platforms could not be understated when they first started. Any platform that connected people, often commercially, now we’re seeing in very short time how quickly that kind of arrangement falls apart. The platform provider simply has too much power, not just over the customers but over the vendors too. When conflicts of interest inevitably arise, we all know what’s going to happen.
This has been obvious from the very beginning, but everyone just buried their heads in the sand and hoped it wouldn’t happen. I wonder what’s the next terrible idea from the past 1-2 decades that will fall next.
I wonder what we can do to remedy this. I mean obviously we have seen this with large forum sites i.e. reddit. Users can and will put up with a lot of BS but there comes a point when there’s just too much BS.
It strayed from being a place for independent artists and crafters a long time ago.
Mass produced crap quickly started drowning out the good stuff after they changed the terms on manufacturing.
It’s a shame because not everyone has the resources to spin up an independent store front, but here we are.
Which is ridiculous because that was the whole point of Etsy, and against terms of service. But Etsy of course made more money from the mass produced crap selling at volume so they let it happen and even celebrated it.
I hate how no business can just keep and maintain a niche anymore. It’s all pivot pivot pivot to more money, add more products, add a social media function, add a streaming service, add an AI service.
Why can’t anyone just stay in their fucking lane.
It’s all marketing too. No matter what you do, you also have to do marketing. Which means give money to companies to show your ads. But you’re competing with companies that have multi million dollar ad spends and you have to spend across multiple platforms. On Etsy itself, on Facebook, Instagram, tiktok, Google, Bing, Pinterest, Twitter, blue sky, etc etc.
I fucking hate marketing. I hate ads and I feel dirty making them. And I hate that it’s just a money suck with very little return unless you have loads of cash to spend on it
The sovereignty of self-owned shop made this possible. I ordered this print: https://warandpeas.shop/collections/signed-prints/products/cats-guide-signed-print. Make sure you visit the shop too.
Interesting, Shopify is considered an improvement? This confuses me since Shopify is just about the easiest e-commerce platform to scrape and they’re doing plenty of stuff with AI too. Everything is on their servers and CDN, and they skim money off the top and sometimes tries to encourage people to use the Shopify app rather than the store’s front end.
I build such sites for a living. But it does seem sad that most online shops are just Shopify ones. Though I get it since self hosted shops can be complicated. I’ve been moving a lot of WooCommerce/WordPress ones over to Shopify.
I’m sure it helps that Shopify seems relatively easy to start using
Don’t have any experience with it, but saw some Etsy alternatives get menioned recently: Hanti (https://hanti.net/) and Makli (https://makli.eu/), albeit seemingly focused on the European market.
I hate the Gammon’s for voting brexit :(
Ah, come on now. I’m sure there’s plenty of other reasons to hate them.
True, but I feel it’s a really good focal point as it was an out pouring of their racism, gullibility, selfishness, little Englanderness all expressed in one act which anyone with two brain cells to knock together could see would be a fucking disaster.
Newer knew war and peas had an etsy shop xD
This reads as if it’s written by AI, lmao
I had the same thought then saw it was war and peas and assumed otherwise. But i don’t feel like your wrong to assume that.
Thanks.
that’s not an accusation. That’s the business model .
is exactly how Deepseek writes in my experience
It’s almost like these systems are trained on human writing and are literally just spicy autocomplete.
Spicy autocomplete. I like it.
Avoiding AI accusations drove me nuts. I changed how I wrote. I tried to keep EM dashes and “if not this, then that” statements. But it forced me to change my writing to avoid sounding like AI.
AI has improved and I am again deconstructing my writing. Not to get better, but to avoid klanker accusations.
That is a new problem for writers.
Yeah but that’s also how I write. Should I change the way I write, specifically dumb it down, so people don’t mistakenly assume I’m using an LLM? It’s fucking bullshit.
Yes
The actual tell is using it improperly. It’s meant to clear up plausible confusion, or at least meant o be used with words that are incompatible. But like in this example they are literally accusing Etsy of those “business practices”. So the “That’s not” is not fitting.
When you use the device correctly it doesn’t carry the same AI feel to it.specifically dumb it down
If you think that phrasing is not dumbed down that speaks volumes.
It’s almost as if I was talking about dumbing down in general.
Why the fuck did you feel the need to insult me?
You wrote your way into it.
That’s also phrasing plenty of human writers have used for a long time before LLMs.
Great, but nowadays it’s a quirk of ai more often than not.
Because it is just copying and regurgitating how many people write…
Also “Legally, that [changes nothing]. Emotionally, [it does].”. The “totally” and “may” aren’t something I’d expect ai to do though.
I hope it’s just an unfortunate choice of phrases.
We’re definitely at the point where people are abandoning devices they used to use to not sound like ai.It’s not even unfortunate phrasing, it’s normal phrasing that normal people use, which is the exact reason AI uses it. Your accusations are just Kafka traps where talking like a normal human being is held up as proof they’re an AI.
I wasn’t accusing anyone, and @ComradeMiao@lemmy.world seems to have been convinced it’s not ai too. If they were even doubting it to begin with.
The thread is about why it feels like ai, it seems pretty clear that it is not actually ai.
Stuff feeling like ai comes about naturally due to the way that it is. “Talking about it is good actually” cause then you learn when to trust it and when not to, and learn to understand it better, and how others perceive it.
It’s a fact that using certain expressions in certain ways will now raise eyebrows.Btw. specifically the “it’s not X it’s Y” one is conditioned on using it poorly (at least for me). I’m sure there are people that legitimately used it poorly before ai, like presumably war and peas here, but it’s definitely not common.
I mean if it was it wouldn’t be as strong a tell.
My “<adjective>, not X. <adjective>, Y” in comparison is a weaker tell. Maybe because it is used properly, or more commonly. Who knows.Also ai doesn’t talk like normal people. It doesn’t even talk like professional writers, though it’s closer to modern pre-ai news article writing than most other styles.
I’m sure it would have the ability to get somewhat close to other styles too, since in initial training the llm will have been exposed to it all and “have to have used it”. But it is trained not to later on, and people generally don’t bother jailbreaking their ai to get it to talk more like a normal person.
Hence also “totally” just by itself being a strong no-ai tell.The thread is about why it feels like ai, it seems pretty clear that it is not actually ai.
Stuff feeling like ai comes about naturally due to the way that it is. “Talking about it is good actually” cause then you learn when to trust it and when not to, and learn to understand it better, and how others perceive it. It’s a fact that using certain expressions in certain ways will now raise eyebrows.
Thanks for a wonderful addition to this thread. Great point!








