I don’t know myself. I don’t think anyone really has an answer.
What you do requires skills. And most people don’t have hose skills. I perhaps view what you do as being a craftsman. You take things that others have shaped and then assemble them into something that is different and more desirable. And there can be craftsmanship and artistry involved by everyone along the way.
I was a toolmaker. I designed and built tools. I sat at my desk and designed the tool in a CAD program, generated tool paths in a CAM program. Then used CAM to create all the G-Code needed. I then sent the program to the machine. I loaded the code and fixtured the piece of steel. At the push of a button the machine did the work as I stood there and watched. Not much different than AI in some ways.
If one sets aside the ecological disaster that AI is for a moment, (and this is the biggest evil IMO). I start wonder if AI is in and of itself “evil” or is it just a tool we haven’t mastered the use of yet. I honestly go back and forth in this. I don’t like AI generated art that is passed off as “real”, but I can understand and be impressed by the skills it took to manage the tool to make that art. I certainly don’t have those skills. But I’m all for the AI currently looking at my MRI scans for signs of cancer cells that even the most skilled radiologist might easily miss at the early stages.
It’s a fuzzy and hazy world. And the older I get, the less sure of the answers I thought I had.
I don’t know myself. I don’t think anyone really has an answer.
What you do requires skills. And most people don’t have hose skills. I perhaps view what you do as being a craftsman. You take things that others have shaped and then assemble them into something that is different and more desirable. And there can be craftsmanship and artistry involved by everyone along the way.
I was a toolmaker. I designed and built tools. I sat at my desk and designed the tool in a CAD program, generated tool paths in a CAM program. Then used CAM to create all the G-Code needed. I then sent the program to the machine. I loaded the code and fixtured the piece of steel. At the push of a button the machine did the work as I stood there and watched. Not much different than AI in some ways.
If one sets aside the ecological disaster that AI is for a moment, (and this is the biggest evil IMO). I start wonder if AI is in and of itself “evil” or is it just a tool we haven’t mastered the use of yet. I honestly go back and forth in this. I don’t like AI generated art that is passed off as “real”, but I can understand and be impressed by the skills it took to manage the tool to make that art. I certainly don’t have those skills. But I’m all for the AI currently looking at my MRI scans for signs of cancer cells that even the most skilled radiologist might easily miss at the early stages.
It’s a fuzzy and hazy world. And the older I get, the less sure of the answers I thought I had.