“Too many” kinda sounds right to my ear because beans is plural, but the second logically seems right because its served by volume and is not ‘countable’ as ordinary (non-destroyed) beans might be.

  • @robolemmy@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    773 months ago

    When it comes to refried beans, “too many” or “too much” are both incorrect. The correct construction is “may I have some more please?”

      • @neidu2@feddit.nl
        link
        fedilink
        13
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        Señor*

        Also, I’d love to see a version of Oliver Twist where the orphanage exclusively serves tex-mex for some reason.

        19th century london orphan taste buds who are used to the blandest of the blandest slop only get to eat really spicy food at the orphanage for the added cruelty.

        • Rhynoplaz
          link
          fedilink
          73 months ago

          HOW CAN YOU HAVE ANY FLAN IF YOU DON’T EAT YOUR BEANS!?!

        • @xiaOP
          link
          English
          53 months ago

          A twist on Oliver Twist with Churro twists.

      • Dem Bosain
        link
        fedilink
        English
        33 months ago

        You can’t have any pudding until you eat your meat.

  • @BearOfaTime@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    32
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    Since the word “beans” is plural, and countable, it’s “many”.

    “Many” is for things that are countable, “much” is for things that aren’t. e.g. Water - you’d say “too much water” but you wouldn’t say “too much cups of water” but “too many cups of water”.

    Though “refried beans” is a thing on its own, I could go either way. Like if you were spooning beans onto my plate, I may say “too much!”.

    How’s that for a confident, clear answer? 😆

    • palordrolap
      link
      fedilink
      63 months ago

      A technically correct alternative would be to drop that plural “s” but forego any uncountable noun that describes the form the beans take: “I had too much refried bean today.”

      In the wrong context it might evoke the idea of one enormous bean that the speaker was unable to finish, but like I say, technically correct.

    • gordon
      link
      fedilink
      English
      43 months ago

      So you’d normally say “that’s too much!” in which case the subject “that” is plural and countable so therefore “much” would be correct.

      Otherwise you should say “you have given me too many refried beans!” since the beans are volumetric and not countable entities.

    • edric
      link
      fedilink
      23 months ago

      I wouldn’t consider beans countable, and would put it in the same category as rice or noodles. So I’d say “too much” is the correct term.

      • @SLVRDRGN@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        23 months ago

        One noodle/ a bowl of noodles. Or one bean, a bowl of beans.

        But you wouldn’t say: one rice. You’d say one grain of rice. So it’s like rice is automatically a mass of many individual bits/grains of rice. Beans are not that way, they’re countable.

  • @SkaraBrae@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    183 months ago

    It depends on whether you’re referring to individual refried beans or the dish ‘refried beans’ as a whole.

    If it’s the former, it would be ‘too many’ (individual) refried beans.

    If it is the latter, it would be ‘too much’ (of) refried beans… Unless you had multiple servings, in which case it would be ‘too many’ (servings of) refried beans.

    That is my opinion: as such it is subject to change should further information come to light.

    • @corsicanguppy@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      1
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      you just discovered why we say ‘traffic’ and not ‘there were many trafficks on my way in this morning’.

      (It’s also why ‘experiences’ and ‘emails’ is very often wrong if we followed established rules like in the former instead of gleefully making up the very exceptions we then curse, like in the latter case.)

  • finley
    link
    fedilink
    English
    18
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    “Too many” if you’re referring to the beans themselves. “Too much” if you’re referring to refried beans as a dish you have been served.

    Edit: just remember: “too many” as reference to a quantity of things, “too much” as reference to a volume or a quantity/amount of a thing. In this case, the “thing” was the dish being served (refried beans). Since it was the dish, itself, being considered (not each individual bean) the phrase was being dealt with, grammatically, as one whole unit— a dish that was served to you, of which you had too much.

  • @chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com
    link
    fedilink
    163 months ago

    Because refried beans are as you mention no longer countable, I think “refried beans” should be taken all together as a singular compound noun rather than the word “beans” modified by an adjective. So then “too much refried beans” is the correct way to say it because it isn’t plural.

  • AFK BRB Chocolate
    link
    fedilink
    English
    113 months ago

    It seems like the problem goes away if you add a “the.” I had too much of the refried beans.

    • @toynbee@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      33 months ago

      Your point is fair, but I respectfully disagree. “Beans” being plural makes me want to use “many.” “I had too many of the refried beans” parses fine for me.

        • @toynbee@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          13 months ago

          I don’t think I’ve ever been asked to quantify mashed potatoes in such a way, but after reflecting for a moment, yes. Thank you for an interesting question.

  • @bionicjoey@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    53 months ago

    Obviously this is very context dependant, but here’s my take:

    “I ate too many refried beans” = in one meal, I consumed more refried beans than I should have

    “I ate too much refried beans” = over the course of an extended period of time, I ate meals consisting of refried beans more frequently than I should have

    • @Asafum@feddit.nl
      link
      fedilink
      73 months ago

      I would think that would be “too much” because all the potatoes don’t matter at that point, it’s one entity. There are no more individual potatoes, we are Borg mashed potatoes!

      • Skua
        link
        fedilink
        23 months ago

        I would instinctively go for “too much mashed potato” rather than potatoes plural, even if I would describe it as mashed potatoes in other contexts

  • @folekaule@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    53 months ago

    Since refried beans is not countable, I vote for “too much”.

    Example:

    • I’m gassy because I had too much refried beans
    • I am gassy because I had too many burritos

    Or like someone else suggested, make the noun singular and call them “refried bean paste”. This will probably raise more eyebrows than much/many confusion, though.

    • @xiaOP
      link
      English
      33 months ago

      NGL… I kinda want to tell someone to reduce their beanage without any context, and walk away.