I’m not about to read the whole thing, but the conclusion includes “Current evidence […] does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages for transgender women over cisgender.”, what kind of junk science have they included?
Well, the entire paper argues for the exact opposite of the conclusion without ever so much as hinting at their own results. They are burying findings that contradict their hypothesis as much as they can, and given that the study is cited as evidence for the opposite of the quoted statement i would say that strategy worked.
I was looking at the wrong paper! Whoops. I was looking at the first one, linked by DragonBallZinn, “Body composition and physical fitness in transgender versus cisgender individuals: a systematic review with meta-analysis”, and I think I just didn’t notice that the second one even existed.
Good to see some better science than that second piece of trash though.
Yeah, the one i was referring to is a study that has already been repeatedly disproven since it came out just 4 years ago. It just makes up a supposed physiological advantage of things that are not changed by HRT without offering any evidence that they actually do provide a competitive advantage in practice, and every time you look at actual performances of trans vs cis athletes there just is zero evidence it makes a notable difference. And that should not surprise anybody, given that transfem athletes have been a thing for ages and there has never been a case of one completely dominating her field in any capacity.
It’s amazing how much of a tempest in a teapot they have managed to cook up. “Have you considered that Lia Thomas drew for fifth?! And Fallon Fox once inflicted injuries that sound disturbing but are actually very common in MMA? Sure, trans people have been allowed to compete in the Olympics since (iirc) 2004 and literally no trans woman has ever won gold, but they still obviously have major advantages!” It’s downright pathetic.
I always love it when chuds use a source that explicitly disagrees with them:
“While transgender women exhibited higher lean mass than cisgender women, their physical fitness was comparable. Current evidence is mostly low certainty and has heterogenous quality but does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages for transgender women over cisgender.”
“Current evidence […] does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages for transgender women over cisgender.”
Ha! Yeah, I got the links mixed up. I thought that study was being used by chuds to support the opposite of the paper’s actual conclusion (wouldn’t be the first time)
Oh I was referring to the other paper, Transwoman Elite Athletes: Their Extra Percentage Relative to Female Physiology that goferking linked. It comes to more or less the opposite conclusion, although I don’t think it’s actually justified by the available evidence. Among other problems, it does not use the usual range for female testosterone levels, and it seems like the author might not understand how spironolactone works? It’s weird.
Wonder if they feel the same about anyone having an a genetic advantage in any sport. 🤔
Edit.
Of course not it’s only bad in transphobic examples 🙃
https://lemmy.world/comment/26767978
What would that be? Trans women do not have any competitive advantages over cis women.
They have a source that says simply having testosterone as a baby/growing up is enough to make it too advantagous for Trans women in sports.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9331831/ - - what they’re using.
And they keep doubling down it’s necessary to remove any advantage in sports only for women’s sports…
Now that’s a load of misogynist junk science.
That’s about all they’ve got for arguments (transphobes)
I’m not about to read the whole thing, but the conclusion includes “Current evidence […] does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages for transgender women over cisgender.”, what kind of junk science have they included?
Well, the entire paper argues for the exact opposite of the conclusion without ever so much as hinting at their own results. They are burying findings that contradict their hypothesis as much as they can, and given that the study is cited as evidence for the opposite of the quoted statement i would say that strategy worked.
I was looking at the wrong paper! Whoops. I was looking at the first one, linked by DragonBallZinn, “Body composition and physical fitness in transgender versus cisgender individuals: a systematic review with meta-analysis”, and I think I just didn’t notice that the second one even existed.
Good to see some better science than that second piece of trash though.
Yeah, the one i was referring to is a study that has already been repeatedly disproven since it came out just 4 years ago. It just makes up a supposed physiological advantage of things that are not changed by HRT without offering any evidence that they actually do provide a competitive advantage in practice, and every time you look at actual performances of trans vs cis athletes there just is zero evidence it makes a notable difference. And that should not surprise anybody, given that transfem athletes have been a thing for ages and there has never been a case of one completely dominating her field in any capacity.
It’s amazing how much of a tempest in a teapot they have managed to cook up. “Have you considered that Lia Thomas drew for fifth?! And Fallon Fox once inflicted injuries that sound disturbing but are actually very common in MMA? Sure, trans people have been allowed to compete in the Olympics since (iirc) 2004 and literally no trans woman has ever won gold, but they still obviously have major advantages!” It’s downright pathetic.
I always love it when chuds use a source that explicitly disagrees with them:
“While transgender women exhibited higher lean mass than cisgender women, their physical fitness was comparable. Current evidence is mostly low certainty and has heterogenous quality but does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages for transgender women over cisgender.”
“Current evidence […] does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages for transgender women over cisgender.”
Wait, just to make absolutely sure. I was pointing to the conclusion that trans women do NOT have an advantage with my study!
I didn’t mean that implication!
Ha! Yeah, I got the links mixed up. I thought that study was being used by chuds to support the opposite of the paper’s actual conclusion (wouldn’t be the first time)
It seems like section 3.1 contains several outright falsehoods, how strange.
Interesting that they still manage to come to the conclusion that trans women don’t have an advantage, then.
Oh I was referring to the other paper, Transwoman Elite Athletes: Their Extra Percentage Relative to Female Physiology that goferking linked. It comes to more or less the opposite conclusion, although I don’t think it’s actually justified by the available evidence. Among other problems, it does not use the usual range for female testosterone levels, and it seems like the author might not understand how spironolactone works? It’s weird.