Damn… brutal burn
Looks like I’m having my yogurt flambé
If anyone has an account for newspapers.com (which somehow belongs to ancestry.com?), the snippet should be here: https://www.newspapers.com/browse/united-states/kansas/elk-falls/the-elk-falls-journal_6709/1905/05/18
Edit: Randall Munroe posted a version of this screenshot on Twitter four years ago https://twitter.com/xkcd/status/1560020008545165319 just noting this to say it might be true, he is either the one who dug it up, or verified the primary source, I’d bet.
The last time this was posted, the underlying joke was that France’s (or Paris’s) oh so grand cuisine was unaware of the existence of yogurt until the 20th century.
I’m genuinely surprised that this was a novelty. I’d have thought that yogurt existed across cultures and time when dairy production is involved.
I’d have thought that yogurt existed across cultures

It has. Well, fermented milk products have been. This might have been some weird thing with a different name. I make my own yoghurt and in the early days I fucked it up a few times by straining it for too long, or something like that. Each time I looked it up to see if it was edible and pretty much every time I found I’d made some different type of fermented milk product from a different culture.
You can tell they’re not talking about yoghurt as we know it because who could possibly eat yoghurt and not find it absolutely fucking delicious?
I have had some plain Greek yogurts that I found almost inedible because they were so bitter. Some fruit, honey, etc. makes it just fine. If the person cited in the clip had a plain spoonful, it might have been a shock to the palate.
across cultures
Nice one 👈🏼😁👉🏼
LOL I wish I had done that on purpose.
It was, just not western European cultures
Some quick Googling indicates that it has been around in Greece for about 4,000 years. Perhaps it’s more a thing in warmer European climates and not so much further north.
I’m probably digging myself into a hole here, but Greece is just barely Western Europe. You generally need warmer climatea which is why the above excerpt from a British person makes it sound exotic.
Greece is not Western Europe other than in a vague economic sense thanks to easy shipping around the Mediterranean and entering the Eurozone early on. Honorary Western Europe is more like it, but a basic East/West divide hasn’t made sense since 1991.
Athens is East of Warsaw, Budapest, and Belgrade. Listen to the music, look at the food, and it leans East due to left over Byzantine and Ottoman influence (now that is how you dig yourself a hole when taking about Greece).
Western European by way of appropriated history from the scientific racism era that in one breath claimed to be the true heirs of ancient Greece and in the other called modern Greeks dirty mixed bloods.
Yeah, like being grandfathered in from Rome fetishization. Romans loved the Greeks. Ergo…
But the Greeks loved the Egyptians and basically owned half of Modern Turkiye, and Western Europeans hate the Browns, so that means the Greeks are not Westerners.
The Romans loved everyone in as much as they wanted to make everyone else into Romans.
To your comment on brown people, I have heard some make comments on whether Italians are white or not. What a strange world.
Yeah I agree that it must have been a completely unknown thing to the British palate. I’m mixed on the question of being or not western, but do not really have a strong opinion.
Yahgurt? More like nah-gurt.
It’s surprising the first time my family had pizza where they lived and how novel it was to them. I’m glad they both exist and I enjoy some low sugar Greek yogurt.
Edit: Then I learned this: Yogurt is an ancient fermented-milk food found across many regions, so it doesn’t have one clearly established place of origin. Its name entered English from Turkish yoğurt. In 1905, an English-language newspaper called it “yaghurt” while describing it as a Paris fad; that was an English spelling, not the French one. French uses yaourt, Bulgarian commonly calls it кисело мляко (kiselo mlyako), and Greek says γιαούρτι (yaourti). English eventually settled on yogurt—the familiar hard g is part of the English pronunciation, not the sound in Turkish yoğurt. (may contain errors lol)
Well, like many things, you have to figure out how to use it, how to make it taste good.
Some things like many vegetables are great as they are - just even better if cooked and seasoned well. But take… pumpkin. You need to extract it, cook it, season it - then you have something tasty. Yoghurt needs to be used in the right way - added to a savory dish, or sweetened with fruit added for a tasty meal or snack.
I do wonder how it might have tasted. Bacteria change, and they could have offered more byproducts. Or they might have had a bad batch or a presentation mismatch. Imagine trying to offer Worcestershire sauce as a dip, for instance
Plain Greek yogurt can also be VERY sour so it may have been like that.
I imagine its just strange if you’ve never had it before, like regular plain yogurt that has a bit of sour taste, then again they probably have eaten cheese and stuff before.
I guess its sort of like introducing someone to kombucha, fermented drink and they think its weird at first, but then they like beer and soda and its like a middle ground to both of those
they probably have eaten cheese
A food correspondent in Paris? I guess it’s within the realms of possibility that they might have stumbled across such fare 🤷🏻
Chicken marinated in yogurt seemed quite insane to me when my Iraqi room mate did it. Immediately changed my tune after being able to create restaurant level chicken schwarma on a whim.
I definitely disliked kombucha the first time I tried it but now drink it regularly.
I used to eat a lot of it, would get the plain and mix in berries and peanut butter granola (yeah yeah, not healthy)
Then the store stopped carrying that brand and I bought a new one. It was…SO sour. I couldn’t even eat it.
plain yogurt is kinda nasty
i love plain yogurt, the problem is that most stores don’t even sell it where I am
It’s pretty easy to make if you can find one live culture pot at the store. We use an instant pot but it’s not the only way. Basically you get more yoghurt by starting with a few spoonfuls and feeding it more milk (boil and mostly cool the milk first to kill the wrong bacteria).
You can use UHT long life milk too.
You can even use plant milk instead of cow milk. I used to make almond milk yogurt before that was easier to find in the stores. I think I used dairy yogurt as my starter. it’s been a while. Almond milk yogurt sets up thinner, iirc.
I love yaghurt
I eat Yaghurt in my yurt.
Bah. It will never take off. Mark my words. What’s wrong with rancid milk anyway?
meanwhile in the nordics: “this fil is too sweet”
The really sour yughurt is great. Don’t care for the sweet stuff










