

Bingo.


Bingo.


Haha, I appreciate it but I doubt my spouse would approve.


Anecdote and personal account obviously varies.
As for Kronstadt, soviet power was solidified. The mutineers wanted preferential treatment and an end to Bolshevik soviets, against the will of the majority of workers and peasants. Their demands were suicidal for the Red Army against the Whites, and Stepan Petrichenko fled to join the Whites shortly after.


Most people living in countries run by communist governments love it. I’d personally love to live in China.


Knowing how people change and grow can also be very hopeful, because we know that by changing society we change ourselves.


You can’t really abolish the state without a fully collectivized global system. They traded a dictatorship of capital to a dictatorship of the working class, which meant all the state structures necessary to protect the socialist system against rollback (until they failed). I maintain that the state itself was never an obstacle to progress, but instead the difficulties with progressing from siege economy to higher developments of socialism.


People are largely shaped by their material conditions, they don’t necessarily have ideas beamed into their heads nor are they exceptionally out of the norm on average.


The USSR was already socialist, the state didn’t get in the way so much as the siege economy ran into problems when needing to develop light industry in the recovery period after World War II. Ideally, they would have been able to properly utilize markets in underdeveloped industry and keep them under the control of the state, rather than letting black markets crop up out of sight because the material basis of markets still existed. This black market led to the rise of a bourgeois class, combined with a weakened CPSU, combined with decades of trying to keep up militarily with the west and draining economic resources.
I don’t think highly centralized firms interacting horizontally is anarchist, anarchism is about highly decentralized firms interacting horizontally.


Romania is a mixed-bag, it was better earlier on but as I understand in the 80s it was rough due to austerity measures by Ceaușescu to pay back IMF loans. Of course I have a different interpretation of Kronstadt than Goldman, I’m a Marxist, not an anarchist, and moreover Kronstadt was spearheaded by a White Army sympathizer anyways. Not really sure what you’re getting at specifically here.
I can’t really disagree that sometimes MLs can be abrasive. I appreciate the kind words, but I also understand that I’m incredibly stubborn, and not everyone is as stubborn as I am. I also have sympathy, because day after day I see incessant and baseless hostility. I just have to learn to brush it off as best I can, but it helps me understand where others with shorter tempers come from.
If you’re interested, we’re actually doing a reading group over on Hexbear.net. Here’s the current discussion thread for week 2, and it’d only take ~90 minutes of reading/listening to catch up before next week starts on Monday. I know you have a Lemmy.world account and thus wouldn’t be able to participate without making a new account, but just lurking and reading the comments can be a nice way to see what MLs are actually like in our own environment. No pressure or anything, though!
Either way, thanks for responding pleasantly.


I’m aware.


For me, I went from liberal -> Socdem -> anarchist -> Marxist-Leninist, and only got firmer in my beliefs as a Marxist the more I studied existing and formerly existing socialist projects, as well as Marxist theory. There’s no one set path, of course, but I like to think that because Marxism is an endlessly evolving and flexible toolset based on dialectical materialism, more and more will come to it in time.
Your personal experiences with MLs aside, the CPC is definitely ML. The fact that they have billionaires is a consequence of having private property, and Marxists don’t believe private property to be a moral sin but instead something that is progressive at some levels of development and reactionary at higher levels. China does have some few homeless people, but the number shrinks every year. It’s enormously different from capitalist countries in terms of how rapidly they are improving for working people.
Sorry that your personal experience has been sour. However, I’d encourage you to put yourself in the shoes of an ML, surrounded by people far to your right. Many end up jaded and short-tempered, it takes a certain level of stubbornness to try to be patient.


Yep. Communism is a global system, built on incredibly advanced productive forces. The various countries controlled by communist parties have always (correctly) considered themselves to be in the socialist stage. Here’s a diagram from Cheng Enfu of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, for example:

Socialism has been established successfully, it’s just an enormous amount of work and development to get to communism, and socialist revolution has primarily come to semi-feudal, barely industrialized countries to begin with.


“Authoritarianism” isn’t an actual mechanism or anything. Every state is a class dictatorship, meaning the ruling class democratically decides nearly everything, and the oppressed class decides nearly nothing. These classes engage in class struggle due to their mutually competing opposite interests, and the role of the state is to cement the ruling class in power.
China is a socialist country, run by democratic councils. Local councils elect delegates to higher councils, that in turn elect delegates to higher councils. In the west, this structure is utterly alien to us, but it’s a far more active democratic system than ritualistically picking heads of state alone every few years. It’s also why Chinese citizens are very happy with their democratic system:

Capitalism is the far more murderous and destructive system. Today, in the late stage of capitalism known as imperialism, Palestinians are slaughtered for land grabs. People in the global south starve to death while the global north pilfers them for superprofits. Famine was forced upon Bengal, where 4 million died thanks to Churchill’s capitalist extraction. Capitalism led directly to the colonization of Africa and the system of chattel slavery practiced in the Americas. The genocide of indigenous peoples around the world came directly for the need of land and resources.
Capitalism has a far higher death count than communism, both by ratio and in total, and it isn’t even close. The US Empire alone is responsible for many millions of deaths in Korea, Cuba, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iran, Yugoslavia, Iraq, Syria, Palestine, Nicaragua, Libya, and far, far more.


It’s simple: DPRK evil. It’s literally Mordor and KJU is literally Sauron in the eyes of most Statesians. They don’t even rationally consider it, because to do so would make it immediately obvious that the comparison is absurd. However, because it’s such an ingrained gut reaction, it bypasses any and all logic and consideration. It’s a call and response, essentially.
?