Wondering what people are thinking about this and why the internet is so quiet about it. I am not happy. Today it decided I couldn’t use the camera without giving it extensive permissions and agreeing to it. Not cool.
You must log in or register to comment.
WDYM?
My camera app (Fairphone) asked me for:
- Location. Makes sense, I set it to record where each picture was taken, can hardly do that if it doesn’t know the location.
- Microphone. Yeah, I wanna record sound in my videos.
- Camera. Duh.
- Files permission. I like my pictures and videos to be actually saved, so this makes sense.
What permissions in addition to these pretty obvious ones does yours want?
Just a FOSS cam app so you know permissions are limited or eliminated.
I mean this one - hopefully - still wants Location, Camera, Microphone and Files, right? Otherwise it’d be pretty limited as a camera. Granted I suspect it only wants Location if I turn on EXIF location as per its description, but the other three would be the bare minimum to work I imagine.
(edit)
Just checked it out, and yeah as expected it of course needs Camera, Microphone and Files. It doesn’t seem to ask for Location even if EXIF is enabled, which maps as it seems to be unable to even record location-of-picture even if desired.So same permissions as both my Google Cam port and the pre-installed Fairphone camera app, yeah.
Yeah that’s going to be the minimum I suspect. Camera for pictures, mic for video, storage for saving those captures and recordings. The actual Google camera app I think requested contacts, read contents in storage, a whole lot of stuff not needed.
I looked at the permissions the camera app has on my phone. While yes it has a few they don’t seem unreasonable to me.
Camera, microphone, photos and video are the absolute bare minimum to be able to capture pictures and video and be able to save them locally.
Notifications while not critical makes sense so it can show a recording notification.
Location once again seems common sense to me because lots of people want their photos geotagged. I believe this is also why nearby devices is required.
I was able to disable location and nearby devices and the app still works, which I think is acceptable.
I’d be curious to see what permissions your camera app has/had/requested to see if it was after more suspicious access.
I use Open Camera. I disabled native camera. Pixel 9pro
^ This, 1000%
Thanks, I’ll try Open Camera. Crossing fingers.
btw be sure to enable camera2 api in opencamera settings (unless ur phone is decade+ old)
You won’t be disappointed, no need to geotag every fucking image…
The thing is I don’t want geotag. I don’t want any metadata on my pics.
Exactly. Open Camera doesn’t need any more permissions than storage and camera, no location services necessary nor required.
I always feel like there is some secret sauce in the google camera app that makes the images look so much better … So i went back
proprietary camera apps almost always come with proprietary post process algorithms that open source apps dont have access to, hence the better photo quality
photoncamera on fdroid has its own post process algorithms that are quite decent but the app itself is a bit janky and seems abandoned
Sometimes you have to uninstall open camera and then reinstall it. It will recalibrate and start being sharp again. Its free and you can have the light on as you like which is great for macros.
What phone are you using? There are thousands of camera apps. If it’s the stock camera for your system, just uninstall/disable it and try another.
Sounds shady but without knowing more details, it’s just speculation.
Unless I’m actively taking a picture I have all the camera permissions disabled and the lenses covered with foil stickers.
On my last phone I straight up deleted the camera app (still covered the lenses with stickers tho) and would download one whenever I had to take photos and delete it again after.
I can’t remember why I stopped doing that actually, maybe the camera app I liked that had none of that tracking shit, got removed or something, idk.
What camera app are you using?
Time for a GrapheneOS phone. The camera app is not the default Google Camera App.
What?
This isn’t iOS. You don’t need to change the whole operating system to use a different camera app. Just install Open Camera and disable the built-in app.
Sandboxed apps on GraphenesOS so if you do decide to use the Google Camera app to access the more advance features then you can still do it without giving google everything.
I.e. motoG had an erase motion AI function, as well as other AR tools but only if you used the Google Camera app, other camera apps wouldn’t leverage it
I think they are getting at is you can still use the Google camera app on Graphene with Network Permissions denied. Open Camera is a great app but I found the pictures came out way worse. I hate Google as much as the next guy here but their camera app is superior.
I could barely afford my bargain basement phone. No pixel or graphene for me, but I’m glad people are able to make better choices. I’m sure it helps the situation for everyone.
Even if you can’t have a GrapheneOS-powered phone, you still can have GrapheneOS camera: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.grapheneos.camera.play
It isn’t as feature-rich as OpenCamera or even native camera, but it does the job and it doesn’t spy on you.
I pay far less for mybused Pixels than a new phone - I refuse to buy new when a 2 year old phone is $150
Nice! I couldn’t exactly plan ahead. One day I had a phone, the next I had a completely dead phone and no way to get into critical accounts. Some days.
Totally forgot about this until now… (thanks) but I remember having to tape a tiny wire to the charging pad on one of my first android phones and then squeezing the (dead) battery pack in on top, because the cursed thing would not initiate charging unless it could read the eprom in the battery pack.
Google and some other authentication providers use to let you generate offline authentication codes. I’m not sure if this is still a thing, but it definitely saved my ass a few times.
I don’t have charging pad. I suspect the phone death was manufactured obsolescence. About 24 hours after google sent a message, the phone stopped charging. I think you mean backup codes. I used them.
They’re almost famous for it… although in the case of a phone, something most of us; hold while charging, sleep next to (or with), etc. an abundance of caution is probably warranted.
What’s a Pixel go for where you are? And what Phone do you currently have?
What?
This isn’t iOS. You don’t need to change the whole operating system to use a different camera app. Just install Open Camera and disable the built-in app.
Get a mirrorless camera! One small enough to carry around.
They can transfer photos to your phone wirelessly, these days.
…Or, as a lesser extreme, a third party camera app.
Even easier is a usb-c card reader so you can plug it in your phone directly. I find the camera connecting apps a bit finicky. (Also “these days” made me chuckle since it’s been a thing for like 14 years now)
Good to know, thanks!
Scouring the camera market has been my intense interest for the past few months, so if you actually looking for one, I might be able to point in a direction.
Like a real camera, not inside the phone? Or app? I suspect the phone is not allowing me to change the default camera. What do you suggest?
For stills, I am a bad source for Android camera app advice because I’m on iOS. But for video, I can tell you the Blackmagic app is incredible.
As for a dedicated camera, not gonna lie, they aren’t cheap. You probably want something used or older, depending on your shooting priorities. Stills or video? Indoor, or outdoor? Fast, or slow subjects? Do you want a lot of zoom, or do you tend to shoot close up? And how much would you spend for a camera you keep for many years?
I hardly ever take video. I take stills, just point and click, nothing fancy, when I want or need. I need a camera app for banking, id, authentication. Also, share photos on Signal and email. Just curious what you would recommend, but I am not buying a real camera anytime soon.
I use a third party app, but didn’t the UK recently pass something that effects the images people take/have o their phones? It’s supposed to protect children.
I remember being annoyed that the standard camera app required microphone permission and that caused me some hassle once. It obviously needs file permissions in order to save pictures. But, I don’t remember it requiring network permissions or anything else especially alarming.
It shouldn’t need microphone permission for taking still photos, or for shooting videos without sound. I joke that Charlie Chaplin was able to make silent movies 100 years ago, but the technology for doing that now seems to have been lost.
What other permissions does it want? What Android version? When I encountered this, it was on my old phone that ran Android 6 at the time (later Android 7).
Android doesn’t have network permission. Any app can access the internet (otherwise ads wouldn’t work).
Well, technically it does. But it’s granted automatically and user can’t even revoke it without using custom ROM.
Charlie Chaplin 😊 I listed all the permissions in another response. Android 16.
