Welcome again to everybody. Make yourself at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread.
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Theory discussion group on /c/theory@lemmygrad.ml
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive
deleted by creator
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
I see Dutch leftists unironically saying we need art against rising fascism like, my guy learn self defense maybe
the art will surely do wonders against groups of football hooligans that cut their teeth fighting either the cops or each other their entire adult life
Join a jiu-jitsu gym and learn to choke
Have a great week, everyone! Stay on top of your habits, keep up with what you need to.
As always, communism will win.
I’m starting your beginners reading list this week :)
Thank you so much! I’m actually about to put out a much smaller guide too, as a sort-of absolute basics guide, so if that sounds more up your alley then I’ll be sure to ping you when it drops!
Hey if it’s too much of a hassle I’d like to get pinged once you’re done also! By what you wrote in that comment lower this approach of two courses sounds better for my frayed ability to concentrate :D
Will do! Still trying to trim it and finalize the list, but will ping you once I’m done!
🙏
Me too please and thanks! Have a wonderful week and happy real New Year, everyone!
Of course!
Thank you!
Sure ping me. Though I’m starting at Section 0 anyways, so I guess there’s gonna be quite some overlap.
Some, but my goal is instead to condense the first several sections into one month-long course, not just an expansion of section 0. I notice that a lot of people seem to drop off the later in the guide they go, so I want to have 2 guides, one barebones and one comprehensive. The current guide will be restructured so as to be more thorough, and the new will be stripped down as much as possible without losing clarity.
Would love a ping as well! I just recently got seven of my friends and I to begin developing a community run Introduction to Marxism-Leninism class using your list. We’re only using Section 0 - 4 for the intro class and if all goes well, we’ll be creating more classes with the later sections.
We just started Week 3 of our prep work. We read and take notes independently then get together in person once a week to synthesize an ‘official’ summary to use for the class once all the material is prepared.
Thank you very much for the list, it’s been very good and has been a great resource for collaborating with my local comrades.
Thank you so much, that’s incredibly humbling to hear! The fact that a guide I made has actually had real-world benefits and utility is what makes continuing to maintain it worth it. Will definitely ping you!
Made a basic Marxist-Leninist study guide as a compliment to my more advanced one! The old guide is getting fleshed out with more dense but valuable works I had left out to keep it as a beginner list, so now the new list is more for brand new people. Feedback welcome!
Pings for those who requested
@Maeve@kbin.earth @prof_tincoa@lemmygrad.ml @DumbBrokeLeftist@lemmygrad.ml @narr1@lemmygrad.ml
Thank you! 🫡❤️
No problem! 🫡
you’re such a dear thank you
No problem, that’s too kind!
Thank you very much!
No problem!
PSA you should also remind Canadians of their genocidal settlers status
And dont leave the aussies out of this either.
Hey Canadians,
You’re no different from Statesians. Stop pretending. Your harboring of nazis and genocide of indigenous peoples in fact makes you very similar to them.
- silly question but are you pinoy :3 .? heh :3
- the way canadians are so dedicated to Enshrining the Victims Of Gommunism, the way they proudly hosted flagrant ukrainian nazis, the way they ignore the fact that their brutal oppression of their natives was equally as sick and deplorable as their Impolite USAmerican counterparts–that sort of blithe deflection and pretense is the most insufferable part. fuck the canadian propaganda of heated rivalry, death to justin trudeau
silly question but are you pinoy :3 .? heh :3
Yes, but unfortunately I live in the US. I should actually start studying filipino (I only know a couple words) and maybe chinese if I ever decide to travel to China.
In a hilarious series of events, the victims of communism memorial no longer contains the names of any people. None of them could be confirmed to be not a Nazi.
ya i know!! kkklanada might as well have just saved themselves the extra metal and just changed the name to “Fascists We Would Have Preferred To Survive Over Red Menace”
What do you mean by the propaganda of heated rivalry?
im exaggerating and mostly joking but i recall its both funded by canada gov (so im predisposed to be wary of it) and it seems to adopt a homonationalist lens in regards to russia. bear in mind i did not watch it for myself idgaf but i have heard avout the plot from people ik (some who r fans) + osmosis basically. as with all things western on the topic of russia it is very russia critical, which is like, usually fine except it’s always unilateral and absolute about the topic when it comes from west which is steeped in russophobia already.
i mean ya, russia is like, famously bad on the topic of lgbtqia. im not saying thats good at all, though similarly to projects like burkina faso thats why i have critical support for them, but i also have seen some writeups for how it has this continuing pervasive anti-russia lens during the runtime, and it’s like, i’m never really going to trust very anti russia plot points from west which continually fails to prove it no longer believes russia is ethnic communist degenerates.
it kind of seems like homonationalism: it has a major focus on russia failures with queer people, i think theres a clip where hes talking to yankees and they insinuate gay sex illegal over in russia (it’s not, ‘lgbtqia propaganda’ isnt which is like, okay, still bad, but im not trusting anti-other-state homophobia position from a yankee) and like, okay. this would be okay at best if not a little clumsy, but then you add in how almost every other russian character apart from ilya and his gf is dickhead and things get weird.
ilya’s big arc with his identity ends with him rejecting his national identity, and the family of his that remains in russia are evil people. his dad at the least is irredeemable jackass and his mom is desd and his brother sucks. the only other pretty nice russian character is his gf who apparently speaks eng and may have dual citizenship. you can see why my skepticism doubles.
overall, it’s a pretty anti russia story, which like, okay, again that would be more acceptable from russian creator, but it’s not, i know it’s canadian product. and i respond to it same way i would respond to usa funding movie about queer chinese girl going to states and completely disavowing her cultural identity because of glorious freedoms. there is room to improve but im not taking the fucking canadians gov word on it bc i know their ulterior motives.
is it that serious? no. not really. its not as bad a piece of propaganda as like call of duty where killing arabs on screen is fantasy teens grow up to fulfill in us army.
but west continues to fund the far right militia in ukraine and uses them as vessel for NATO expansion, which canada has had a big role in, all while not examining homophobia locally in terrorist states of usa and canada, and my contempt for it is kind of enhanced becausw canada gets away w its soft power bullshit since people think its Nicer than USA, and it continues to be very russophobic so no i dont give heated rivalry benefit of doubt
ETA: rereading chinawatcherwatcher comment and actually finally taking in that ilyas dad is evil abusive man who was in high role in russian gov WHILE HAVING DEMENTIA completely convinces me. already people chomp for russia regime change but like, i have no doubts this show is sowing it further however subtly
i watched it and had pretty mixed feelings about it all around. as far as the russophobia is concerned though, i actually thought everything to do with ilya’s (the russian main character) family had much worse implications than anything else. the issues for queer people in russia are at least believable, but the ancillary stuff was not: ilya’s father was both an important figure in the government, and also suffering from dementia at the same time, for multiple years (i mean, really???). and ilya’s brother was a coked up exploitative asshole trying to milk ilya for everything that he was worth. that stuff really stuck out to me as russophobic, because what kind of government except a totally inept and fake one would keep on a prominent figure with dementia? this despite all the issues in the past with western gov leaders having dementia (biden, reagan, possibly even bush, etc).
oh yeah. ive heard a lot about the family itself bc ilyas dad is jackass who we are meant to hate, mother dies cuz her relationship w him is bad and she khs, brother is mooch who then goes on to hate on him when he comes out or whatever or refuses to send money back. so it’s like, kind of cartoonish evil but i didnt say cuz i didnt see the arcs, in general if that’s what the russian rep is like, almost unilaterally dickish except for ilya who chooses to leave russia and then goes on to hate on it (i think he says he doesnt want the passport wtf doe she mean) that’s pretty bad. aladdin levels of ‘subtle’ racism
didnt know he had dementia though so funny bruh. incompetent senile oriental despots!
the only other russian representation in the show is a woman who is his longstanding “deep friends with benefits,” but she’s played off as being more worldly and therefore less russian: she speaks english fluently, she travels to see him in various US/canadian cities, etc etc. otherwise yes, all of the other russians in the show are definitely cartoonishly evil lol
like at best ik western people are going to consume this and its going to feed their already very negative and lacking understanding of russia (slava ukraini is a phrase so many non ukrainian people seem to repeat uncritically) which, alone, wouldnt be the problem since someone seeing something thats criticizing something worthwhile (homophobia) and then interpreting that wrongly/extending it disproportionately and untruthfully is stupid silly and their problem but the most uncharitable writeups ive seen have basically reported on peculiar stereotyping in the show which if u understand russophobia as a permitted orientalism just makes it like. weird and possibly dehumanizing for group that people have come back around to being called asiatic hordes in recent years
again, idgaf, honestly, the show not important for all the words i spend on it, but like, tjats just my critical take. and any canayank jerkoff content already pisses me off to be honest
sorry im sleepy whenwriting this, it not very good and iwill edit for coherence
how could i forget. fuck every canayank that pretends they are any different from usamerikkka
新年快乐!Happy chinese new year everyone! Hope your year is full with good luck and good organizing.
Happy Chinese New Year to you comrade
Ooo, ring of fire eclipse, I nearly forgot!
Anxiety has been killing me these days, i feel so powerless just observing my country and other latin american countries just standing still against the ongoing genocide preparations towards Cuba. Like when are we going to start developing ANY deterrence against the fascist americans, there is a negative amount of sense of urgency here.
Soon

god please let this happen it’d be so fucking funny
but muh
!
Christians will complain about how lgbtqia+ is so confusing while having 100+ different denominations that are supposed to be just following the teachings of one guy
REAL IDENTITY: yeah i’m poly and a panromantic asexual, i’m also agender and go by they/xem/fang
FAKE IDENTITY: i’m a Jehovah’s Witness
ULTRA FAKE IDENTITY: i’m a Mormon
every time i pass this comment i must add one more gender/sexual identity or pronoun, it’s a toll
i wish china and the dprk had more counterops/botfarms in the anglosphere internet than conspiratorial libs say they do. like cmon man please
DPRK bots save this sorry dead internet
ive said this a million times i’m so sick of anticapitalist posturingonline that isn’t ML. i’m so so so sick of it bro. because it ends up going full swede socdem (as Joseph Stalin said… socdem is the leftwing of WHAT) and then they go back to hating evil gommunist totalitarians and then it’s like, literally all revolutionary potential being squandered in front of u, and its worse that now they’re extra inundated with anti-AES talking points, and now are the most effective anti-communists of the bunch. yes, chomsky and other compatible left intellectuals were cultivated to produce such outcomes, but there’s also wholly organic examples
After quitting my job I have decided to walk the Camino to Santiago from my house. It will take me probably three months, maybe more if I do some side quests.
Afterwards I will write my version of the Motorcycle Diaries.
This is an excellent idea. Everyone should do a Haj whether it is to Mecca or just hitting the road with nothing but what they can carry. There is something zen and psychically purifying about making miles. I loved life on the road but my back loves nights in a bed.
Reports in our media of the US attacking Iran this weekend. No idea if legit, though.
Seems inevitable, Narco Rubio speech was a declaration that good ol’ masks off colonialism is back on the menu and he received a standing ovation.
As gramsci said, the old world is dying and the new one is struggling to be born, now is the time for monsters. Neocolonialism is dead, now we either win or go back to ol’ colonialism.
Scary times
looking at the military build up it seems to point to either this or next weekend
I doubt it. The ford is still a couple weeks away from the area.
I hope you all have a nice week :D
You too, Oppo! 🫂
You too, comrade!
You too, Oppo! (●‘◡’●)
You too thanks comrade 😊
Reddit has this hate boner for Eileen Gu because she chose China over the US to represent at her sport and schooling everyone else doing so. They can’t handle someone not wanting to compete for the US, even less so if China is the one instead.
Probably residual Ellen Pao hate boners.
https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/mco7b9/what_is_the_deal_with_ellen_pao/A Reddit link was detected in your comment. Here are links to the same location on alternative frontends that protect your privacy.
In the Sopranos episode ‘Christopher’, there is a scene where a Turtle Islander (presumably Philip Ng) gets into an argument with somebody counterprotesting on behalf of Columbus Day, and the Turtle Islander yells ‘He fed our people to his dogs!’ to the counterprotesters.
I have a feeling that that was an oversight since Columbus never set foot in what we now call the United States, and I get the feeling that the Turtle Islander was from one of the northern tribes (the Mohawk, maybe?) rather than from the Caribbean. That said, if there are Turtle Islanders who sincerely see the Caribbeans as part of their people, that is really cool of them! I don’t expect many, sheerly due to the degrees of separation, but it is absolutely possible.
A lot of people are under the misconception that Columbus landed in mainland North America, and I would be unsurprised if there are even indigenous adults who think this, which leads me to pessimistically assume that the solidarity is unintentional. I would love to be wrong about this, though.


















