• 54 Posts
  • 757 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 24th, 2024

help-circle
  • but those might also be qualities that have resulted in success

    I can only speak for my own state here, but I wouldn’t call their situation a success, given their potential. Looking at the number of members, the level of dedication they demand from members, and the financial power many of their membership have, their outcomes over the past decades are disappointing and suggest serious flaws.

    One org in particular, one highly regarded in terms of non-sectarianism and general behaviour even when people disagree ideologically, is half-filled with former SAlt members who were burned out or mistreated. Their outsized impact and institutional power within the progressive movement (antifascism, anti-war movement, pro-refugee advocacy, unions) is a merit to their collaborative attitude.

    Victorian Socialists don’t seem like a blank extension of the “cult-like” mentality people claim about SAlt… they seem distinct/different enough.

    Agreed (with an asterisk), linking my other comment: https://aussie.zone/post/38472405/26145427


  • It’s inaccurate to characterise VicSoc, or the Socialist Party in general, as merely SAlt’s electoral project, even in areas where they dominate, simply because Socialist Alliance withdrew. I’m familiar with oppositional caucuses and independent members in each active state, with varying degrees of power and ability depending on state. In Victoria, for example, non-SAlt have been successful in collaborating and creating better outcomes for the party: https://partisanmagazine.org/2025/11/18/socialist-unity-an-independent-perspective/

    That doesn’t suggest the opposite either, that SAlt’s dominance should be ignored. In NSW in particular, which I suspect is exceptional and doesn’t represent other states, the Sydney SAlt faction have consistently behaved destructively and significantly, measurably hindered the growth of the party (such as preventing the creation of new branches, visible harassment of perceived opposition within the party, and stacking an antifascist coalition then neglecting their obligations).




  • I’ve been so busy I didn’t even notice the 2026 Victorian state election approaching at the end of the month.

    A few comrades are discussing this ad, and while it does take a workerist perspective, I think that’s fine for what it is and it’ll probably go down well with the general population as a whole without becoming an issue for those not currently working.