cultural reviewer and dabbler in stylistic premonitions

  • 1.62K Posts
  • 1.95K Comments
Joined 5 年前
cake
Cake day: 2022年1月17日

help-circle








  • https://libreboot.org/news/clankers.html

    gif animation of dwayne 'the rock' johnson applauding

    Cheers to Leah for having the courage to publish this refreshingly honest expression of the extreme cognitive dissonance which so many of us are enduring at this very difficult time in history.

    There is much in this text which I wholeheartedly agree with, including:

    • I personally think AI is the worst thing we’ve ever built
    • Libreboot proposes a name for current iterations of generative AI: Weapons of Mass Intellectual Destruction
    • I think the world was better off without AI, but I can read [this article] and regard it as entirely reasonable.
    • I don’t think AI is going away

    and also many parts which I disagree with, such as:

    • You cannot simply tell an AI with a few prompts to gut a binary and start writing source code from it. That’s not how this works. (this often is how it works now, actually; it pains me to say it, but, saying that it isn’t indicates that one is operating on outdated impressions of model capabilities 😢)
    • Think again! (while you still can) - see: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.09089 (The title of this paper is “Measuring the Impact of Early-2025 AI on Experienced Open-Source Developer Productivity”. I think its assessment of what the situation was then is probably accurate, but this bears very little relevance to the present situation today in November 2026. Even open weight models from more than six months ago are drastically more useful than the best proprietary models were in early 2025.)
    • A most recent example of where Libreboot de-slopped itself was this patch: https://codeberg.org/libreboot/lbmk/commit/0ff23c0f520c9f98aad243f3304a46af0742753b - an otherwise good patch fixing a bug was optional and thus reverted. (this doesn’t seem like a good example at all, because afaict the upstream coreboot “slop” patch being rejected here actually is very small, well explained, easy to understand, and is also reviewed by four different people - at least one of whom i recognize as a long-term (pre-AI) coreboot contributor.)
    • It remains to be seen what the full long-term consequences of AI are, but I basically think nothing good will ever come of it. (contrast this with “I can say credibly that there are several initiatives underway in the coreboot project right now that would not be possible without AI” elsewhere in the same document).

    The long-term consequences obviously remain to be seen, but it is clear that many very good and very bad things have already come from it and will continue to in the near term.

    I wholeheartedly agree with this part of her conclusion:

    • I will not do a disservice to my users by denying them the opportunity to make use of otherwise good work - if I can help someone replace proprietary software on their computer, I will, and the manner in which it was developed is of no concern to me.

    Thanks again to Leah for publishing this, and for writing (and continuing to write) free software, and for trying to maintain some optimism in this very difficult time we’re in.





























  • Arthur Besse@lemmy.mltoOpen Source@lemmy.ml•Ban AI Slop?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    9 天前

    I don’t really want to become the judge of what is “heavily-AI-assisted”.

    imo it doesn’t really take much in the way of judgement; usually it is pretty obvious when there is one developer and the README is written in LLM voice and the project is a few weeks or days old.

    I think if I were to write a rule I would focus more on self-promotion in general than trying to decide how AI assisted it was

    I think that would also be a good rule, but wouldn’t stop people from promoting others’ slop or from promoting their own while pretending it isn’t.

    I would generally rather rely on user votes to decide if it is “worth it” or not

    unfortunately there are sometimes cases (such as the post i deleted here yesterday) where a post will have mostly upvotes despite being not-even-open-source. there are also things which are freely licensed, but get many upvotes despite being absurdly bad vibe-coded ideas - eg, this centralized IPFS web directory making contradictory privacy claims 🫠 (imo that should be deleted; what do you think?)



  • Arthur Besse@lemmy.mltoOpen Source@lemmy.ml•Ban AI Slop?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    9 天前

    Curious. Woke up to find my post removed at almost exactly the same time you posted this, complete with an accusation of “slop”.

    yes, after a brief assessment i concluded (correctly, i see now after taking another look at it) that your project is exactly the kind of new, single-developer, vibe-coded slop which i think we should not accept the promotion of here… and yes, seeing and deleting your post was what reminded me that i’ve been meaning to post something in this thread.

    however, after i deleted it for being slop, i also noticed another reason it is not suitable for this community: as @thingsiplay@lemmy.ml helpfully pointed out in the comments, your README says this:

    To that end, I’m publishing the current 32.71 source code and final release, with the source code frozen at this version.

    Download the APKs from the SmartTube LOCAL GitHub Releases page.

    I’ll continue to publish updated APKs as I hatch them.

    So, it isn’t even an open source project going forward: the released source code is “frozen” and future versions will be binary-only? so, in this case you actually shouldn’t post this in the !aials@lemmy.ml community either 🤦

    fwiw i am personally not completely opposed to AI-assisted coding; i am also doing some of it myself. however i think everyone should be skeptical of new single-developer vibe-coded projects - most are very low quality and will be abandoned in the near future.

    The latter leads to things like this.

    This is exactly what the new community is meant to address: to have a place for people to share their AI-created softwares without getting a flood of hate for it being made with AI.


  • Arthur Besse@lemmy.mltoOpen Source@lemmy.ml•Ban AI Slop?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    9 天前

    imo this community should have a rule against posts promoting new primarily-written-with-an-LLM software projects. as an admin, i’ve deleted a few myself when there are reports of them and the mods aren’t resolving them.

    banning all AI-assisted software is obviously no longer reasonable now that many large and old projects are using it (with varying levels of care…) but I don’t think we actually need a very firm definition of “slop” to be able to say some things clearly are slop and some AI-involved things clearly aren’t. When in doubt about if something is of sufficient quality that we should keep it here, the age of the project and the number of developers involved are useful secondary metrics.

    @gary_host_laptop@lemmy.ml created a new community which I think should be linked in the sidebar here as an alternate place for sharing these things. How about this for a rule (in the !opensource@lemmy.ml sidebar)?

    This is not a place to promote new single-developer heavily-AI-assisted projects. Another community exists for sharing AI-Assisted Libre Software: !aials@lemmy.ml

    note that the word “slop” is intentionally absent from my proposed rule (and from name and description of the community) - the point is that this is a place for people to share their AI-created software, regardless of if it is 100% vibe coded or is actually high-quality “agentic engineering” - only time, review, and users will ultimately tell which category many of these new things fall into. But enough of it is slop that we shouldn’t have this community flooded with it, imo.

    cc @CrypticCoffee@lemmy.ml @Lettuceeatlettuce@lemmy.ml @kevincox@lemmy.ml