• 23 Posts
  • 4.27K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle


  • Again, no. Anarchist literature is an in-group. Do you consider the conservative definition of “homosexual” meaning “homosexual child groomer” to be correct as well?

    Again, “involuntary hierarchy” is a fine and accurate term. Generalizing that term to just plain “hierarchy” is in-group jargon. The fact that many anarchists use it that way doesn’t make it any more correct than conservatives using “homosexual” to mean “homosexual child groomer”.





  • This really seems like it only makes sense in the context of contrived definitions of “authority” and “hierarchy”. Expert Authority (authority deriving from an individual’s expertise in a particular field) is a well-established and widely recognized concept.

    “Hierarchy” does not inherently imply that the relationships are involuntary. If you want to call such structures “involuntary hierarchy”, knock yourself out, I’ll agree with everything you say against them. But voluntary hierarchies are still hierarchies by the actual definition of the word, and when the structure is based on expertise (judges, teachers, trades experts, administrative coordinators, etc) they are extremely effective.

    Redefining words to exclusively refer to the most negative aspects of the common definition is bad rhetoric, intellectually disingenuous, and ineffective at spreading a message. Like I said, if you would like to be specific, and append an appropriate adjective to existing words to refer to a particular subset of a concept (involuntary hierarchy, arbitrary authority) you’ll have much more luck convincing those who know what the base words mean.



  • Interesting, GURPS has a couple mechanics kinda like this. You build characters with point buy, and you can “buy” Disadvantages like Cowardice or Alcoholism which have a negative point cost, giving you extra points to spend on other attributes.

    There’s also a way to spend points that you earn (you earn points by adventuring like exp) to change things in the world slightly, though I don’t really use it.

    Also, there’s a fun attribute called Common Sense, where the GM warns you if you’re about to do something particularly stupid.