ButtBidet [he/him]

  • 491 Posts
  • 3.47K Comments
Joined 5 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 28th, 2020

help-circle



  • however Brian tries to portray Otpor as much more influential than it was… but it wasn’t the entire movement, nor was it the majority, nor was it the driving force… Otpor had 1 seat in the parliament ( out of 250), and in the subsequent elections held in 2003 where they went independent, they had 0 seats and dissolved shortly after in 2004

    I have to say, this has been my experience with Berletic, where he portrays the (possibly) most Western controlled NGO as the leading org, and thus the whole movement as Western led…

    I got to the point where you questioned whether or not Otpor was a Color REvolution Op

    That’s not how I read OP’s text.

    BTW, I can’t insist enough how I know feck all about Serbia. Maybe it is a colour revolution. I just don’t trust Berletic’s analysis on anything.


  • Ya I don’t know anything about Nepal either, but I’m much more inclined to believe actual leftists. I’ve been beating the drum against Berletic for years. A few people in the news thread love him too hard and are beyond reason.

    In situations like Ukraine where many people here have a lot of background knowledge, he’s probably less bad as people can critique him. But when he drops opinions on places like Indonesia, Myanmar, Nepal, and Serbia, places where nearly all of us have very little local understanding, he can do real harm. Clearly this one YouTuber can’t be experts in all these places, so he’s very much talking out of his ass much of the time.

    You’re not the first local I’ve met who’s found his “colour revolution” spiel to be overly simplistic, with them also raging that “Western backed NGOs fully creating a coup out of thin air” is spurious. I’m friends with a few Myanmar refugees, and his defense of the junta there is just comically bad if gives it just a critical read.

    I’ve never known Berletic to have a good opinion on any issue or even show a wiff of social justice or leftism. The attraction Westerners have for him is so weird.






  • I can see you point. As a dude, I’m not gonna argue it. But I do fell hella uncomfortable being around visibly respiratory illness sick people. Like, why do I get compelled to get your germs? But it someone else argues it’s too far, I’m not gonna push back.

    I have very immune compromised friends. For them it’s a much bigger deal, and they probably have stronger opinions on this than me.