cross-posted from: https://lemmy.sdf.org/post/62061673

Archived

[…]

Otago University’s China foreign policy expert Associate Professor Nicholas Khoo says [Auckland mayor] Brown is ill-informed and did not understand the complexities of international politics.

[Brown said in an interview with Stuff, amongst others, that “democracy had its day” and praised the Chinese autocracy during and after a visit to China.]

Brown’s comments were “problematic because they’re simply inaccurate”, Khoo said.

[…]

While democracy had experienced “some issues” in recent years, he agreed with British wartime leader Sir Winston Churchill’s assessment: It was the worst system until you considered the alternatives.

Brown also suggested the Five Eyes partnership (an intelligence arrangement between New Zealand, Australia, Canada, the US and UK) was a waste of time.

He believed New Zealand should sell its membership to Japan.

Khoo disagreed: “Mayor Brown is not particularly informed on these issues,” which was concerning given his role as mayor of the largest city in the country and a person able to influence public opinion.

“So this is something for us to reflect on and perhaps even consider whether we need more basic understanding of the virtues of capitalism and democracy and also our security alignments.”

He added that democracy and capitalism had worked well for New Zealand and its allies.

Brown, who has been visiting China for 20 years, would have been on a business-related tour stage-managed by the Chinese government, Khoo said.

The mayor should have his “eyes open” because it was obvious his comments would be used by the Chinese for propaganda purposes, he said.

"He needs to be much more clued in.

“And for someone who likes to think he’s clued in with things, it is surprising he’s making these sorts of less than tactful comments and certainly were not reflecting the realities and complexities of international politics in the current era.”

Khoo did not want to comment on the US ambassador’s view in a subsequent interview on RNZ’s Checkpoint programme on Wednesday that Brown had been captured by the Chinese government, except to point out reports by New Zealand’s Secret Intelligence Service had pointed out the concern over China’s behaviour.

[…]