In short:
An animal rights group that secretly planted cameras around a Victorian goat abattoir has won a High Court challenge over laws determining who owns the rights to covertly captured video footage.
The case involved a director and an employee from Farm Transparency International who installed cameras at a halal abattoir in Eurobin, in north-east Victoria.
But the group has been ordered to destroy its recordings, which it said would stifle the public’s right to know what happens inside slaughterhouses.
Questions about who should own the footage were only taken up on appeal, when the court determined that ownership was allocated to the abattoir, not the activists who collected it.
The court used a mechanism called a “constructive trust” to assign ownership to GMC.
It is a remedy imposed by a court when property arises from wrongdoing, but it has never been applied to such a copyright case before.
Alliance for Journalists’ Freedom executive director Peter Greste said “the judgment reinforces the importance of political communication and free speech in Australia”.
Human Rights Law Centre associate legal director Kieran Pender said the decision “prevents development of law which in other cases may have allowed perpetrators of alleged wrongdoing to acquire copyright in order to prevent public interest reporting”.
"This is an enormous blow to the public’s right to know what happens in slaughterhouses and factory farms.
“We will comply with the orders and delete all copies of the footage in our possession, but we will never stop fighting against cruelty and injustice.”
Thank you, Farm Transparency International for doing what is ethical and compassionate. Shame on the legal system and on our abusive treatment of animals.

