So, in other words: which of your core beliefs do you think has the highest likelihood of being wrong? And by wrong, I don’t necessarily mean the exact opposite - just that the truth is significantly different from what you currently believe it to be.
Probably the belief that there (isn’t) some kind of omnipotent god interested in guiding our affairs. It’s not like I’d ever be able to know. How would I cope? Pretty easily. It’d be comforting. That’s a pretty good reason to doubt it, since I’m biased in favor of it.
The thing is, I’m not picking this one because it’s the most likely one, but because all of the other “core” beliefs are either completely subjective judgments that can’t be “wrong” or are flexible enough that it doesn’t really matter.
And omnibenevolent? A god that’s just screwing with us is feeling relatively more likely these days, and I’m not comforted.
that part is tautological. if the almighty is perfection, then benevolence is defined by it, not by us. so the only way one can consistently hold that belief is to admit that we are the imperfection. we are the disease, we are punished. i guess that’s why i dont believe that shit lol
Yeah, that’s often put forward, but I never really found the argument satisfactory. A deity can tell me starving children is benevolence all it wants, and that just means that it’s using the word differently from me. I don’t care how impressive it is.
yeah the concepts of good and evil dont really make sense when addressing the divine.