Basically title. Is it common to use some kind of RAID for backing up other RAIDs or do people just go with single drives?

  • @entropicdrift
    link
    English
    19 months ago

    Could always use UNRAID for the backup if you’re trying to be storage efficient, but it’s really no better than RAID5

      • folkrav
        link
        fedilink
        English
        3
        edit-2
        9 months ago

        Unraid’s “killer feature” is the ability to mix and match disparate drive sizes and only requiring the parity drive to be at least as large as your largest data disk, a la MergeFS/Snapraid. Also ZFS chugging RAM like there’s no tomorrow so not really an option for underpowered devices like some NASes. But yeah, TrueNAS is nice.

        • @s38b35M5@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          29 months ago

          Thats is a very budget-friendly choice for UnRAID to accept varying drive sizes. As a backup destination, especially a cold backup, the RAM requirements of ZFS should be less impactful. I had lots of use from my TrueNAS box with 16GB, and my dedicated cold backup build is just 8GB on 5x1TB WD Blue (gasp!) HDDs. I always wanted to try other NAS platforms, but I’m away from all my tech for a few years.

      • @BearOfaTime@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        English
        29 months ago

        Lol.

        If you have a spare box doing little, and a bunch of drives, it (or unRAID) are reasonable solutions. Proxmox can also build RAID with random drive sizes - I’m running one with 3 drives, using ZFS RAID 0, it has a terabyte of storage.

        Yep, it’s gonna suck when one of those drives fail.

        • @s38b35M5@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          19 months ago

          Well as long as you’re aware of the risk and prepared for it, its not so bad to run in a volatile way like that. I ran my TN box for almost a decade on the same USB boot before I finally caved and picked up three Intel enterprise SSD for the job, with one as a cold spare. Nothing in the vox was critical or would be missed for more than a few beers of crying.

    • @BearOfaTime@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      English
      19 months ago

      Yep, all RAID has the same kinds of issues - largely sensitivity to X number of drive failures. Which is part of why we see RAID 6 (double parity), Mirroring, RAID 1-0, etc, all as mechanisms to provide compensation for disk failure within the RAID.

      In the SMB, RAID 10 seems to be the favorite approach today for NAS/Virtualization hosts (ESX, etc), with backup going to a cloud provider such as iland or barracuda.