Note: It’s become clear to me that so far the vegan community on Lemmy (unlike Reddit) is lacking and overrun by non-vegans. So please only answer this if you’re actually vegan. I’m seeking a vegan perspective on this.

With that out of the way, is it speciesist to have a favourite animal? Many vegans consider themselves dog 🐕 lovers or cat 🐈 lovers (“ailurophiles”) first and foremost, aside from animal lovers (who actually respect animals hence their veganism) in general. Others, like Joey Carbstrong, say that pigs 🐖 are their favourite animal and always have been even since before they went vegan; maybe some saw the movie “Babe” and developed an affection for them, for example. It’s understandable. And others like cows 🐄 or chicks 🐥 or lambs 🐑 of course.

But as much as it might be a natural thing to gravitate to a certain species of animal, and “favouritise” them, is that still a form of speciesism? Of course if you’re not actually exploiting the animals that aren’t your favourite then it’s only a mental matter. But is it still wrong even just to view them differentially and prefer or hold more love for some species than others? Loving an individual than another makes sense. But would you love one race of people more than other? Do you say “Greek people are my favourite race” (as a non-Greek person, for sake of example)? If not, and if that would be considered racist, then why is it not speciesist to prefer one species over others, even if just mentally?

  • @Lemvi
    link
    17 months ago

    The point is though, treating them all equally doesn’t make any sense because based on their species they have different needs.

    Some animals enjoy the company of humans, others do not. Some radiate a calmness that is appealing to some, while others have an enthusiasm that more fits other personalities. So when getting a pet, why would you ignore all that?

    Should I get a crocodile as a pet just to treat them all the same? I wouldn’t be doing that crocodile any favour, nor myself.

    I guess its that old “equality vs equity” debate all over again.

    • @Grapetruth@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      17 months ago

      Sorry I missed this comment.

      Treating them all as equally well as possible makes sense, to be clear. That means not exploiting or harming any of them unnecessarily.

      But treating them in exactly the same way doesn’t, since they have different needs and considerations as you point out. I agree with that.

      And I’m not saying we should have all animals as pets, in fact due to the suffering it causes I would be wholly against the domestication of any more animals.

      But we don’t have to treat animals in the same exact ways in order to respect and love them equally, even remotely or conceptually, even just based on the knowledge of them. It does feel strange to me to say “this species is my favourite species”. Is it speciesist? I’m not sure. It’s definitely not as bad as exploiting species selectively. But it might have some remnant of the views that led to those practices in the first place, potentially. I’m conflicted about it like another vegan said here whose comment was deleted.

      • @Lemvi
        link
        17 months ago

        I guess that I disagree with the notion that it’s bad to feel a certain way. We cannot control how we feel, only how we act.

        And frankly its just unrealistic to ask people to love mosquitos just as much as they love cats.

        I don’t need to love an animal to acknowledge their capability to suffer and to try to avoid causing any suffering to that animal.