Just reposting this excellent point from lemmygrad

  • nickwitha_k (he/him)
    link
    English
    410 months ago

    First of all, thank you for the good and productive discussion and not assuming malice or sectarianism. Neither malice nor sectarianism were indeed meant; quite contrary, I want for us to learn from these events and encourage empathy and positive interactions in the hopes of avoiding such in the future.

    In retrospect I can see how I completely misphrased my viewpoint. It is dehumanising, you are correct. However it is not the people killing the royal family doing the dehumanising, it is the system which they exist in itself. From the moment those kids were born they were royals, and that fact made them into something other than people. That other thing cannot exist without being a threat to a democratic society.

    I don’t entirely disagree there and thank you very much for the Robespierre, I’ve not read him directly before. I find myself that much more glad that such decisions have not been required of me. Royals were not always royals, so, I do not believe that it is something immutable about them the moment that they are born. But, in the context, at the time, I cannot say that it was not the way to save the most lives.

    Either way being hung up on these events from a time before we were born seems very counterproductive to me.

    Absolutely. I just want to do what I can to avoid rhyming with the harms caused by such divides and help keep it hard to dehumanize our comrades in this struggle.

    While I agree it is not specific, I’d like to point out that is a meme. It’s not supposed to communicate more than a thought, not an entire concept. It is posted on a leftist forum, and it is assumed you can somewhat interpret its meaning on your own. It’s not supposed to be taken 100% seriously, not everything has to be serious all the time. It’s meant as joke for us and a threat towards those harbouring a transphobic sentiment.

    A very good point. I may have been a bit extra sensitive there due to having been close to kids who suffered senseless violent deaths and my own personal baggage.