Yeah, TOTP is great. If people would stick to that, we’d be good.
There is such a thing as more security than is worth the inconvenience, though. If it’s some really non-sensitive thing, and it ends up with more that two effective factors, it seems like that point has been passed. In some cases, I trust the service about as much as would-be hackers, too, so the additional information to send the 2FA is itself a breach.
There’s every reason to think the conventional wisdom about 2FA is right, but that it’s always better, regardless of situation, and implementation, goes beyond it.
Yeah, TOTP is great. If people would stick to that, we’d be good.
There is such a thing as more security than is worth the inconvenience, though. If it’s some really non-sensitive thing, and it ends up with more that two effective factors, it seems like that point has been passed. In some cases, I trust the service about as much as would-be hackers, too, so the additional information to send the 2FA is itself a breach.
There’s every reason to think the conventional wisdom about 2FA is right, but that it’s always better, regardless of situation, and implementation, goes beyond it.