For me, it’s probably a toss up between Sekiro and Bloodborne. I’ve finished the games in their entirety probably around 4-6 times - either for their respective endings, just for fun, or trying to do a challenge run, like a BL4 Bloodborne run. Lies of P follows them closely at around 4 and soon 5 once the DLC rolls around.
Bloodborne and Sekiro were my first two soulslikes, and once it clicked, I was obsessed with both. I got platinums, watched video essays, listened to the OSTs all the time. They’re very near and dear to me.
What is your most-played soulslike?
Sekiro and Bloodborne for me too. DS1 in third