The registration process doesn’t validate (bad)email addresses resulting in non_recuperable accounts
Can you DM me the account name you’re having problems with?
My concern is more with the involuntary trashing of the namespace : an account registration should be dropped if not validated after a certain amount of time.
Yes that’s a good idea, could you raise it as enhancement request here: https://github.com/LemmyNet
Please, can someone (lemmyist) with an account on GitHub do this … as I have no knowledge about it 🙏
Maybe the request for improvement (to be raised on GitHub) could be as such :
Lemmy account registration should be dropped if not validated after a certain amount of time. Old databases should be revised. To be applied only where an email is required for registration.
Edit : Better yet : the registration page should not drop until successful registrationPlease be so kind to reply here after you raise it 👍
Oups ! i should have posted to :
Lemmy.world improvements and issuesEdit : Many had similar issues :
… @again@lemmy.world // here
… @stoulram@lemmy.world // hereWhat about users who want to intentionally register without an email address? Maybe to give more anonymity to their account?
This is note possible in my instance, so I missed that !
There are some instances that don’t require emails, albeit mainly privacy-focused ones though with manual account approvals
They are not going to die that.
There really isn’t a reliable way to “validate” email addresses other than to try sending email to them.
An email address has two parts, separated by the @ sign: the “local part” and the domain. The domain has to follow the rules of DNS, but there are astonishingly few hard rules for the local part.
A validator can check that the domain resolves — that there’s an
AorMXrecord for it in DNS — but it can’t do much about the part before the @ sign.Whether the local part is correct or not depends on the actual behavior of the mail server for the domain; which means that, without actually trying to send email to it, it can’t really be tested.
You’ll want to get in contact with your instance admin to get that untangled
I did contact him inside this post, now I realize it’s a problem for each and every instances !
Edit : in fact, only the instances that requires email for registration.
