Since yesterday I’ve basically been crippled by thoughts about suffering which is inherent in our nature, and is not solvable in an ethical manner. I can’t really think of or do anything else.
This does not (in this case…) concern the suffering caused by humans, which can – at least to some degree – be mitigated.

I’ll try to keep it short.
Basically, I just thought of the relationship between predators and prey. The prey might eventually escape, but possibly with extreme and awful injuries. Or if the predator is successful, it might end up being ripped apart while still alive.
That is horrible, and creates strong feeling of compassion for the prey.
BUT, that’s only true if focusing on the prey. Let’s now imagine the predator’s side. Possibly starving, also injured from unsuccessful fights, possibly even with hungry young offspring waiting for their parent (the predator) to bring them some food so they don’t starve as well.
Which is what makes it shitty – it sucks, yet there is no (ethical) solution.

I’ve also questioned the ethics re-introducing predators to areas where they were made extinct, compared to something like contraceptive population control. Doing it (eliminating predators) on purpose would (in my opinion) not be ethical, as we’d have to destroy life (as we already did in many places). But in places where this was already done, could it be a more ideal method of population control?

Lastly, there’s a question of general human involvement in nature. While this wasn’t originally a concern I had, some people in discussions I looked up had mentioned it as well.
This concerns if, and if so, up to what degree is intervention ethical.
E.g.: Only helping if harm was caused by humans, vaccinating against rabies, removing parasites, treating injuries, etc.
I.e.: Where should a line be drawn.


Welp. Possibly it should be easy to not think about, considering the many atrocities happening. However, there being something worse (in terms of suffering), doesn’t make something awful better.

This has also led me to discover something called Negative Utilitarianism, which is a view of prioritizing the minimization of suffering.
But just like Utilitarianism, which aims to maximize happiness, it results in some absurd outcomes.
More specifically, one outcome. A 100% solution to ending all suffering – annihilating all life.
While being technically correct, it is a quite absurd solution.

In online discussions I’ve also found people compare the suffering caused by such a “solution” to the total suffering of continued life.
But that brings me to question whether it’s even possible to quantify and calculate suffering of multiple people.

Let’s say 11 people show up with some injuries. They are asked to rate their pain on a scale of 1 to 10. There’s 10 people with a paper cut who consider their pain a 1. The last one is a person with an open fracture, who considers their pain to be a 10. Is their suffering equal and comparable?
This would only get more absurd on a larger scale.


So yes, I am going a bit insane. Horrors within my comprehension, some without a solution. I wish to have not been born.

  • kindnesskills@literature.cafe
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    6 minutes ago

    This has also led me to discover something called Negative Utilitarianism, which is a view of prioritizing the minimization of suffering.
    But just like Utilitarianism, which aims to maximize happiness, it results in some absurd outcomes.
    More specifically, one outcome. A 100% solution to ending all suffering – annihilating all life.
    While being technically correct, it is a quite absurd solution.

    Prioritising doesn’t mean doing nothing else. I can prioritise work over my health and family, but I’ll still sleep at night and celebrate birthdays. I’ll just order more takeout, get up and hour earlier than I should and visit family for a weekend instead of a week… to make more time for my priority without making it the only thing in my life.

    You can prioritise lessening suffering where it’s reasonable without going to the extreme of removing all suffering for all time. Prioritising just means that when you have a reasonable choice to make, you choose your priority - having a priority shouldn’t be unreasonable or unrealistic. You can still accept plenty of suffering, just like I can accept plenty of time off work.

    In the same vein: minimising doesn’t mean completely eradicate. Some suffering will always occur. Some suffering is good even. The goal should be “trying to minimise suffering” (not “successfully minimising suffering” or “ending suffering”) because trying can help you make choices and guide your behaviour. Accept that suffering will happen, but try to make it last shorter and make it’s impact less overwhelming.

    For example: Don’t avoid relationships because you risk suffering heartbreak, but make choices to try to lessen/shorten the suffering once heartbreak happens.

    In general your not going to solve anything by going to extremes. Having moral and ethical goals can be good, not because you should do nothing else until you achieve them but because they can guide you in small ways throughout life. They should be like landmarks to help you orient yourself when you get off track, not like railroads where every slight veer off track means catastrophe.

    …

    Why use just a few words when blabbering on incessantly does the trick of hammering home my point repeatedly. Hope any of it made sense.

  • Duchess@piefed.linenoise.vip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    16
    ·
    edit-2
    5 hours ago

    Personally the Buddhist four noble truths and eightfold noble path have been my guide. I think of it more like a mental martial art than a religion the way I practice it.

    Life is suffering. The act of rebellion against entropy that is life is inherently a struggle. Every being suffers in this fashion from the moment they are created, fighting for each breath and calorie.

    The beauty of the human experience is to be aware of this, and to seek a relief from it, just like you are doing now! I wish you success in this quest, however you find it.

      • Duchess@piefed.linenoise.vip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        edit-2
        2 hours ago

        Life does increase entropy in a system overall but does so as a byproduct of decreasing it locally in the form of highly organized cells. Our immediate struggle against it is what causes the suffering under discussion!

        • pebbles@sh.itjust.works
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          2 hours ago

          I mean I wouldn’t say we are struggling against entropy I’d say we are facilitating it. But yeah that is pretty pedantic. Maybe I ought to watch less David Mitchell lol.

          • Duchess@piefed.linenoise.vip
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            2 hours ago

            Life takes in low-entropy energy like sunlight and simple chemical bonds and gives off high-entropy waste like heat and co2. It’s these activities of organizing and processing that is the struggle to live. So yes we facilitate entropy but it’s an effect of persisting, every living being carries code to replicate, organize and survive. Without that effort there is no struggle and no suffering.

            The Buddhists call this organizational drive taṇhā!

            • pebbles@sh.itjust.works
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              1 hour ago

              Oh curious! Which Buddhists focus on that? I’ve only closely studied Chan Zen.

              Do you think something that has no desires can suffer?

              Without understanding qualia it is basically impossible to confidently speak about the intentions of non-humans. I’ve filmed some microbes that sure looked like they suffered. But I can’t with certainty say they had the intention to survive or if I just iterpret certain movements as pain.

              • Duchess@piefed.linenoise.vip
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                28 minutes ago

                taṇhā is the core of the second noble truth so is shared across all the Buddhist sects. My own studies are largely under Theravada which uses Pali. Mahayana and Vajrayana branches would call it the Sanskrit tṛṣṇā. The Chinese terms are unfamiliar to me I just looked it up and it seems like 愛 (ài) or 渴愛 (kě’ài) are closest.

                suffering under Buddhism (dukkha in Pali) doesn’t require the same pain/distress connotations that we assign in the west. It’s more a sense of unsatisfactory-ness. The paramecium moves towards and eats another microbe to satisfy the innate unease of conditioned existence. To live is to suffer in this fashion. Every creature is born hungry in its own way.

  • susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    12
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    2 hours ago

    Life is suffering AND joy. They are like yin and yang. Our perception of both is defined by evolution and socialization; and subjective.

  • Rentlar@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    3 hours ago

    Okay, based on what you’ve written reminds me of a saying that came up in the preamble of a book by Murakami I read recently, which might help since the concepts of pain vs suffering are getting a bit mixed by the sounds of it.

    “Pain is inevitable, suffering is optional”.

    Think of this lighthearted example, if you’re looking down while walking and bump against a wall, your hands will go to hold where it hurts, that’s a reflexive pain response but you’re not exactly suffering besides calling yourself a dumbass. Whereas, one time I fell off a bike and broke a bone in my arm, what was worse than the shock and pain, was being told of the potential to permanently lose motor function (luckily wasn’t the case in the end), those thoughts are what caused me to suffer. Even if that loss were to be realized, eventually I’d have to decide whether I want to make peace with that or just keep suffering even though I can’t do anything about it.

    Existence for any creature in this world involves some pain. Suffering is harder to measure… since I’m not a zoologist I don’t know that much to tell the difference between a non-human amimal’s pain response and an expression of suffering. In many cases with household animals it’s a vocalization like a whining dog, changes in social behaviour, or the position of something like the ears of a stressed horse.

    I don’t subscribe to the idea that one’s joy must always comes from another’s pain or suffering, clearly your suffering right now is coming from the mere thought of others suffering, so I think the inverse, joy inspiring joy is possible too. Your thinking suggests you have a high amount of empathy for others, which is good. Just remember to recognize where your brain is taking shortcuts and making assumptions like “any pain for a creature is always suffering” to keep you in a doomloop.

  • moakley@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    4 hours ago

    A macro scale problem requires a macro scale solution. This isn’t something for you to solve; it’s for humanity to solve.

    Early humans were required to have a much smaller window of empathy. They couldn’t afford to have empathy for a tiger, for example, because the tiger could kill them. They couldn’t afford to have empathy for a chicken, because they needed to eat that chicken to survive.

    Then humanity advanced. Now we have the luxury of reintroducing wolves into the wild. Now we have the luxury of pitying the tiger in the zoo and wanting him to live in a sanctuary instead. Soon we’ll have the luxury of lab-grown meats to replace the factory farm industry.

    Every generation is more empathetic than the one that came before it. You’re feeling so strongly this way because humanity is moving in the right direction (overall on a large scale not just looking at the last ten years). We won’t solve it in our lifetimes. We won’t ever solve it completely. But we’re getting better all the time, and you don’t have to carry this burden by yourself.

  • rah@hilariouschaos.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 hours ago

    crippled by thoughts about suffering which is inherent in our nature, and is not solvable in an ethical manner. I can’t really think of or do anything else.

    That’ll pass.

  • silly_goose@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    4 hours ago
    1. By learning to accept suffering. Remember that nobody can escape it.

    2. Adopt a lifestyle that minimizes the suffering of other sentient beings. This might involve eating locally grown plants, volunteering at animal shelters, donating to charities, being frugal, and avoiding air travel etc.

  • Micromot@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 hours ago

    Having predators allows a natural balance of the relationship between predators and prey, which works much better with other natural processes like decay etc.

    Overall the regional predators do a much better job at upholding the ecosystem than humans can.

    If we think about removing the predators from a habitat it also leads to problems for the prey as well. They tend to overpopulate the area until the food available isn’t enough anymore. I can’t find the study anymore but there was one about a population on an island without natural predators.

    This leads to suffering as well, as many animals will die from starvation as well.

    You need to think of the whole ecosystem when adding or removing factors, only when it is balanced it can keep a stable state. This is the beauty of ecosystems.

  • danekrae@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 hours ago

    “Existence (which includes suffering) in its entirety is good.” - Boethius (Consolation of Philosophy)

    He was on death row and suffering when he wrote that.

    “Existence is suffering” is the common translation of the First Noble Truth of Buddhism. They call it Dukkha I believe.

    My favorite book currently, because it helped me so much with thoughts like you are having, is The Daily Stoic: 366 Meditations on Wisdom, Perseverance, and the Art of Living. Happy by Derren Brown is also really good.

    • AskewLord@piefed.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      4 hours ago

      existence is only suffering if you make it into suffering.

      like OP has decided to do.

      not to mention one person’s suffering is another’s pleasure.

  • pebbles@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    4 hours ago

    The hardest part for me is that there is no coherent definition of suffering. I also desperately want to be able to do moral math but the hard problem of consciousness forces us to just live in ambiguity.

    But it is okay. We only have so much power, so it is best to just focus on how we can move the needle in the right direction. Go vegan or join a mutual aid group or something lol.

    I agree that is probably literally impossible to make a world free of suffering that still has life.