Honestly, some really good points being made here…
DNS resolver blocking is a blunt tool that strips away whole domains at a time, meaning all content is blocked - legal and illegal alike - and does so in a completely non-transparent way.
And it’s like redacting a single map. Not only could you just bypass the map if you know directly where you’re going, you could also just get another map of the same area!
All that running the big public DNS resolvers out of town does is push people towards lesser known resolvers that are much less transparent and accountable.
To your second paragraph. Not sure where I read it (I think the context was CP) but I found this comparison quite fitting:
“Blocking DNS entries is fighting symptoms instead of fighting the disease, the servers with the material are still there.”
I see them as an additional security layer - known phishing site? Known malware site? Block them at the DNS level now and you have already several potential victims saved, while you go after them and take them down completely which might take some time (hours/days/weeks).
But that assumes that you actually try to do the second part…
Lesser known is not necessarily a bad thing. Part of the current problem with the internet is consolidation into fewer and fewer hands. We could do with more, not less. However the problem is to ensure they are trustworthy, as you mention.
Honestly, some really good points being made here…
DNS resolver blocking is a blunt tool that strips away whole domains at a time, meaning all content is blocked - legal and illegal alike - and does so in a completely non-transparent way.
And it’s like redacting a single map. Not only could you just bypass the map if you know directly where you’re going, you could also just get another map of the same area!
All that running the big public DNS resolvers out of town does is push people towards lesser known resolvers that are much less transparent and accountable.
To your second paragraph. Not sure where I read it (I think the context was CP) but I found this comparison quite fitting: “Blocking DNS entries is fighting symptoms instead of fighting the disease, the servers with the material are still there.”
I see them as an additional security layer - known phishing site? Known malware site? Block them at the DNS level now and you have already several potential victims saved, while you go after them and take them down completely which might take some time (hours/days/weeks).
But that assumes that you actually try to do the second part…
Lesser known is not necessarily a bad thing. Part of the current problem with the internet is consolidation into fewer and fewer hands. We could do with more, not less. However the problem is to ensure they are trustworthy, as you mention.