Why Newcastle Private proposal amplifies issues at Mater

By Lucy Miller
November 5 2026 - 12:35pm

The prospect of Calvary Health Care taking over Newcastle Private Hospital has rightly sparked outrage about people’s access to health care without discrimination. But there’s something conspicuously absent from the debate.

The Mater hospital in Waratah is run under a public-private partnership. While it essentially operates as a public hospital, it is owned by Calvary Health Care.

As a Catholic healthcare organisation, it follows the Code of Ethical Standards for Catholic Health and Aged Care Services in Australia.

That means access to healthcare, including abortion, IVF, contraception, gender-affirming care, sterilisation and voluntary assisted dying (VAD), is restricted.

These are legal healthcare services, and yet the religious beliefs of a hospital operator are determining whether you can access them.

As a woman living in Newcastle, it’s important to me that these services are available, but also that they are accessible to anyone who may need them. Women deserve to be able to make decisions about their body, their health and their future with a doctor, based on what’s right for them.

The proposed takeover of Newcastle Private has highlighted this issue. Obstetrician and fertility specialist Dr Denise Nesbitt has warned that more than 1000 IVF patients a year could be affected if fertility services are lost. Important ethical questions raised by the license transfer of Newcastle Private and Hunter Valley Private to Calvary are amplified further for people who rely on, or choose, the public health system.

The Mater is one of our major public hospitals, providing hundreds of thousands of outpatient services each year to people across Newcastle and the Hunter. Its dedicated healthcare workers provide essential care. But restrictions imposed by its Catholic operator mean some services aren’t available, shifting the burden onto other hospitals, including John Hunter.

Access to healthcare shouldn’t depend on what you can afford, or whether your medical needs align with a hospital operator’s religious beliefs. We have a chance to change that. The Mater has been engulfed in turmoil over the failure of its complicated public-private partnership arrangements. Staff and patients have endured years of maintenance problems, including mould, water leaks and serious safety concerns.

A NSW Parliamentary inquiry exposed the consequences of managing a public hospital through a web of private contracts.

None of the maintenance faults at the Mater relate to the Calvary contracts, but the questions over relying on complex governance arrangements for public services at a public hospital persist. The inquiry unanimously recommended ending the failed partnership and returning the Mater to public ownership and management.

The NSW Labor government is due to respond to the inquiry findings and recommendations this week. Fixing the hospital and ensuring patients and staff are safe must come first. But repairing the buildings while leaving the clinical governance untouched would be a huge missed opportunity.

The Mater’s entire operation, including day-to-day clinical management, should be returned into the hands of NSW Health. We should expand the range of healthcare available there by ensuring that the scope of services is left to medical professionals, not impacted by religious doctrine.

In 2023, the ACT government took over Canberra’s Calvary Public Hospital, bringing its operations into public hands. Religious restrictions on reproductive healthcare had also been a concern at that hospital. If Labor can do it in Canberra, why can’t it do it in Newcastle?

Local Labor representatives have spoken out about the potential application of the Catholic Code at Newcastle Private, we must insist that this commitment extends to the Mater. If reproductive healthcare is worth defending at a private hospital, then it’s worth defending at our public hospitals too.

Religious rights should be protected, but that right shouldn’t extend to deciding what healthcare someone else can receive at a public hospital.

Newcastle deserves public hospitals that are genuinely public, in their ownership, management and the healthcare they provide. Labor says it supports safe, public services for all. It’s time for them to prove it.

Lucy Miller is the Greens candidate for Newcastle in the state election