Another day, another update.
More troubleshooting was done today. What did we do:
- Yesterday evening @phiresky@phiresky@lemmy.world did some SQL troubleshooting with some of the lemmy.world admins. After that, phiresky submitted some PRs to github.
- @cetra3@lemmy.ml created a docker image containing 3PR’s: Disable retry queue, Get follower Inbox Fix, Admin Index Fix
- We started using this image, and saw a big drop in CPU usage and disk load.
- We saw thousands of errors per minute in the nginx log for old clients trying to access the websockets (which were removed in 0.18), so we added a
return 404in nginx conf for/api/v3/ws. - We updated lemmy-ui from RC7 to RC10 which fixed a lot, among which the issue with replying to DMs
- We found that the many 502-errors were caused by an issue in Lemmy/markdown-it.actix or whatever, causing nginx to temporarily mark an upstream to be dead. As a workaround we can either 1.) Only use 1 container or 2.) set
proxy_next_upstream timeout;max_fails=5in nginx.
Currently we’re running with 1 lemmy container, so the 502-errors are completely gone so far, and because of the fixes in the Lemmy code everything seems to be running smooth. If needed we could spin up a second lemmy container using the proxy_next_upstream timeout;max_fails=5 workaround but for now it seems to hold with 1.
Thanks to @phiresky@lemmy.world , @cetra3@lemmy.ml , @stanford@discuss.as200950.com, @db0@lemmy.dbzer0.com , @jelloeater85@lemmy.world , @TragicNotCute@lemmy.world for their help!
And not to forget, thanks to @nutomic@lemmy.ml and @dessalines@lemmy.ml for their continuing hard work on Lemmy!
And thank you all for your patience, we’ll keep working on it!
Oh, and as bonus, an image (thanks Phiresky!) of the change in bandwidth after implementing the new Lemmy docker image with the PRs.
Edit So as soon as the US folks wake up (hi!) we seem to need the second Lemmy container for performance. So that’s now started, and I noticed the proxy_next_upstream timeout setting didn’t work (or I didn’t set it properly) so I used max_fails=5 for each upstream, that does actually work.
server load is too low, everyone upvote more stuff so i can optimize more
edit: guess there is some more work to be done 😁
Upvote causes an endless spinner on Liftoff. 😁
I’m getting 504 gateway time outs when I try to upvote
For me it works way better than before
seems like it may have been a temporary issue. It’s clearing back up.
It doesn’t for me actually. Maybe just on Lemmy.world?
I don’t understand your graph. It says you are measuring gigabit/sec but shouldn’t the true performance rating be gigabeans/sec for a Lemmy instance?
deleted by creator
And where’s the statistics for days between each core dump? A healthy instance should have at least three days between each one
Depends on whether they have fiber or not.
I see what you did there.
Beans have tons of fiber!!
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
gigabean/s
heh
aye aye sir, to the upvote machine!
Double the image upload size and you will see more shitposts
I was gonna argue that you’d see more bean posts, but at this point they’re the same thing, both in the pun sense and the literal sense
Web-ui is very smooth rn… is this .world?
😅
Joke aside, the improvement is like heaven and earth. Love it!. Good work teams!I’m on another instance, but here’s some federated activity for you.
All hail @phiresky@lemmy.world! Today is your day. You have made the single most valuable contribution and you must be celebrated! Bravo! Hurrah!
I was just going to post a meme about choosing either creating activity or spare the server from overloading. Now the joke won’t stick.
deleted by creator
Test:
Upvote if you can see this comment. 👍
Looking good from here.
Edit: And comment rapidly going through. :)
Can’t see anything…
Shame you’re getting no karma. Take my upvote.
Oh, I thought that was the joke 😅
Like a tongue-in-cheek, remember our silly old Reddit ways kinda thing.
Ha. I don’t miss it. I upvote for good content.
I think i was on r for a year or two before I learned what karma was. I still don’t understand it’s value.
I can see and upvote this comment. 👍
I can also see and updoot yours. 👍
502, sorry mate.
Damn, better luck next time.
The change is noticeable. Good job guys.
Thanks for the updates.
I agree. Felt it immediately when I started browsing. Everything is faster and more responsive, on top of the error messages disappearing
Yup I can even post comments first try, without getting an error! Things are working well!
Really noticeable. Cool update. Thank you, guys! ❤️
This is why having a big popular instance isn’t all bad. It helps detect and fix the scaling problems and inefficiencies for all the other 1000s of instances out there!
This, if everyone kept just spreading out to smaller instances as suggested in the beginning, while still a sensible thing to do, no one would have noticed these performance issues. We need to think a few years out, assuming Lemmy succeeds and Reddit dies, and expect that “small instance” will mean 50k users.
I sincerely doubt reddit will die anytime soon, it’ll just exist as its own thing that it’s new target audience gets bored with and moves on from in a few years when something new and flashy catches their eye in the app store. Just like they do all the other apps designed in exactly the same fashion that reddit is currently morphing into.
Meanwhile Lemmy will be slowly building it’s communities up to be what reddit used to be.
I’m actually kinda waiting a few releases to start promoting my instance anywhere, letting some other brave instance admins work the kinks out a bit first.
Agreed. I decided to keep my community on lemmy.world specifically because of the community investment I see being put into it.
If this project is to stay for the long haul, we gotta load test it and stabilize it. These folks are doing the important work here. Large instances are more or less inevitable if Lemmy sticks.
Wow. So much smoother today.
Great work.
You dropped this 👑
Damn tootin.
You’re gonna be when you see how fast I can bean post now.
You guys had better quit it with all this amazing transparency or it’s going to completely ruin every other service for me. Seriously though amazing work and amazing communication.
My upvote can go through fast now
Good work
I love the smell of updates in the morning.
Thank you guys for your awesome work!
Also to other people: DONATE TO FOSS PROJECTS. If 50.000 people donate only 0.5€, we have 25.000€ for funding the servers, coding, motivating/ people etc. Just don’t take a cup of coffee for 1 day. We are already 2 millions in Lemmy instances. We can build a decentralized world together!!
You can pry my cup of coffee from my my cold, dead hands.
Will donate anyway, I really want this project to keep going.
euro contributed 🫡
you inspired me to serve the greater good!
For example, if you speak a second language, you can even help with translation in projects. Its very easy. E.g. I translated the Jerboa (Lemmy client for Android) in Greek 2-3 days ago. I needed only 1 hour to finish and special 15-20 minutes for fixes that I missed, yesterday.
Is there a good link? One for USD?
If there’s a thing you really need to pay in a foreign currency, look into Revolut or Wise. Since I occasionally have to pay stuff in Turkish lira, GBP and donated to USD-only Receivers I like to keep Revolut as my secondary bank account since exchanging one currency to another is completely free!
I’m not sure wtf you just said, but lemmy.world feels very smooth today, so thank you for your continued hard work!
Boy does it feel good to have those reports and understand the work you guys do. It’s really inspiring! Thanks for your hard work, everything has been silk smooth! This instance is really great, Lemmy and its devs are really amazing and I feel at home in a nice, cozy community.
Am I getting this correct: the whole lemmy.world instance run in one single container on one single host?
You’d be surprised at how much performance this kind of setup can squeeze off. Often the limitation is more on the DB/storage than network handling and processing power.
This. Most of the time, the bottleneck will be the database backend.
Curious if lemmy.world uses separate reader/writer instances.
Impressive if true!
if it runs this well on a single container, considering the amount of users it has, I fear the power it’d hold with more
Lemmy is built on an async work stealing runtime and you can get very large instances from Amazon and the like.
I’m sure the instance isn’t massive but number of containers and a single “host” are not great indicators of efficiency.
So that’s why it was so smooth today… Great work!
Certainly feels fast today!
Submitting PRs is literally the most effective response that helps everyone who uses Lemmy. Thanks to you all.
This is better optimization than most enterprise devs will see in their lifetimes.
