I don’t follow the development super closely so I don’t know if those issues were resolved or not. I just remember a lot of discussion on it when I was first on Lemmy on a different instance.
not that i’m aware of, and fixing a database schema once it’s already in place tends to be a clusterfuck so i’m very skeptical it will get better any time soon
Deletions shouldn’t be difficult because of the schema. For instance, this query: select display_name, ('https://your.lemmy.host/pictrs/image/' || pictrs_alias) as image_url, pictrs_delete_token from image_upload iu innerjoin local_user u on u.id = iu.local_user_id innerjoin person p on p.id = u.person_id; will list all media, with the display name of the user who uploaded them, and the token that can be used to delete the image. Obviously, this needs a where u.id = ? parameter to only expose the list to the right user, but adding a “delete old media” page really shouldn’t be that hard. It’ll require time, though, and with one of the two devs taking parental leave soon, I don’t think there’s that much dev time for a while.
The pieces are almost in place, they just need an API endpoint and some UI work.
That query by itself in a vacuum is fine. Combined with many other triggers on the DB, and then federating that out before actually deleting from the local DB… well that is what creates all sorts of headaches.
Images aren’t federated through ActivityPub so I don’t really see how deleting media is supposed to work.
Yes, they are. Every instance downloads everyone’s images for a “cached” version that is currently never used. This is what makes this problem especially insidious and straight up dangerous in cases like CSAM.
not that i’m aware of, and fixing a database schema once it’s already in place tends to be a clusterfuck so i’m very skeptical it will get better any time soon
Deletions shouldn’t be difficult because of the schema. For instance, this query:
select display_name, ('https://your.lemmy.host/pictrs/image/' || pictrs_alias) as image_url, pictrs_delete_token from image_upload iu inner join local_user u on u.id = iu.local_user_id inner join person p on p.id = u.person_id;will list all media, with the display name of the user who uploaded them, and the token that can be used to delete the image. Obviously, this needs awhere u.id = ?parameter to only expose the list to the right user, but adding a “delete old media” page really shouldn’t be that hard. It’ll require time, though, and with one of the two devs taking parental leave soon, I don’t think there’s that much dev time for a while.The pieces are almost in place, they just need an API endpoint and some UI work.
That query by itself in a vacuum is fine. Combined with many other triggers on the DB, and then federating that out before actually deleting from the local DB… well that is what creates all sorts of headaches.
deleted by creator
Yes, they are. Every instance downloads everyone’s images for a “cached” version that is currently never used. This is what makes this problem especially insidious and straight up dangerous in cases like CSAM.