I’ll start with maybe I just don’t know enough about open source. I do understand that the code is available and people can see it, make suggestions or adjustments, or essentially make their own thing using some or all of the code. I’m all for sharing things as necessary and learning from others when possible. With this though, I personally am on the side of: I trust ljdawson to do what’s best for this app. I am on the sync train because of him the incredible app he made, and how he leads and interacts with the sync community.

I’ve been using Sync for about 7 years and I’ve always thought Ljdawson is very active with the Sync community and (from my experience) has been pretty receptive to feedback on his app. When the material you version of Sync came out, people didn’t like it so he made it so you can choose between the material you look or the old look. There are tons of customization options. I feel very informed with each update as well as what his next plans are. There are paid features that both support him as a dev and the longevity of the app. He puts a lot of time and care into creating the product we get to use and for me that is more important than being able to access the source code.

I understand the worry for sure. My gut says that stems from the current situation at reddit, but I personally don’t think the answer is sync going to open source. If something crazy happens with sync, there are (currently) other options.

  • pfzfqsm2
    link
    fedilink
    11 year ago

    I’d say it’s akin to Chrome and Chromium.

    Along with the release of Chrome, Google open-sourced and released a predominant part of the source code and released it as a Chromium project, which is open source.

    But Chrome has more features and dropper integration with Google services and telemetry. And you have the likes of Edge which is Microsoft’s fork of Chromium with their own features. But separate enough to compete with Chrome.

    So you can still keep the main source code of the app open source but keep all the proprietary on a closed source fork. Good for competition and allows the main developer to make money