• @fatalError
    link
    22
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    You can get thin clients for much less than that… Better performance if needed, similar power efficiency for similar loads, they sometimes bring storage, power supply and ram and you don’t generate more e-waste as these are already being thrown out by many big companies every few years.

    The only reason to go for the PI is if you really need the GPIO, the tiny form-factor and even then there are cheaper alternatives with similar or better spevs.

    • bioemerl
      link
      fedilink
      179 months ago

      It’s all about the idle power and software support.

      • Avid Amoeba
        link
        fedilink
        99 months ago

        🌈 The software support! 🌈

        Anything that runs on an SBC has a Pi image. Download, write, go. And Pi OS (Debian) for anything else. Or Ubuntu LTS.

      • AggressivelyPassive
        link
        fedilink
        49 months ago

        Thin clients are just regular x86 boxes, they’re miles ahead of every SBC. The only downsides for consumers are slightly bulkier sizes, slightly higher power draw and of course the gpio/Hat ecosystem is not available, but I would argue that for most people that’s not really relevant.

      • @somenonewho@feddit.de
        link
        fedilink
        29 months ago

        Yeah. As someone running a NAS/Jellyfin server of a SBC/USB SSD I would love to pick up an x86 sffpc too properly put everything inside but idle power and quiet aren’t easily beat.

        Software support olinwouldnt really agree since x86 gives a lot more options than ARM

        • AggressivelyPassive
          link
          fedilink
          49 months ago

          My RPi 3b pulls 5W, while my thin clients draw about 6-7W on idle, one of them doesn’t even have a fan, the other one could easily be modded to lose the fan.

    • DopamineDaydreams
      link
      fedilink
      8
      edit-2
      9 months ago

      Uhuh, for work we love raspberry PIs as they’re small enough to stick behind a wall mounted TV and good enough to run our display apps. All for the low price of £80~. I’d love it if you have viable alternatives.

      • @fatalError
        link
        39 months ago

        When I was looking for a pi4 I stumbled upon orange pi, rock pi, banana pi and libre computer. They have models both cheaper and more expensive than the rpi. All depends on the specs you need.

      • Briongloid
        link
        fedilink
        79 months ago

        You can buy 7th Gen Intel 4-core with 16GB DDR4 & 128GB SSD for cheaper than a Raspberry Pi 4.

        I have both a Pi4 & a ThinkCentre which is significantly more powerful, doesn’t take up much more space.

        • atocci
          link
          fedilink
          89 months ago

          I don’t know, I think that might be overstating it a bit. Even the highest cost 8GB Pi 4 model tops out at $75 without accessories but I can only find 2 listings on Ebay at the moment for MFF PCs that can beat that price, also without accessories.

          • @upstream@beehaw.org
            link
            fedilink
            59 months ago

            eBay is not where we buy new hardware.

            Pi has been ridiculously expensive and hard to get from 2020 to 2023, and we’ve had applications where we’ve been deploying them.

            Think we’ve seen cost up to $200 for a complete kit.

            You need power, SD-card, a case, and depending on application also a micro HDMI adapter. It all adds up.

            Slight difference if you are just upgrading in place, but comparing the unit price of a bare Pi to a computer with everything that you need is not apples to apples.

            • atocci
              link
              fedilink
              49 months ago

              Wait where are you getting these things new for that price? I’m interested, but the lowest I can find is this. I brought up ebay because it was lowest price I could find, but if they’re even cheaper new, I could use one.

              • @upstream@beehaw.org
                link
                fedilink
                3
                edit-2
                9 months ago

                No idea where the other guy is getting his Lenovos. We’ve been buying Pi’s because of form factor and GPIO.

                We had a fair share of those Lenovos in the office when I started (I think they were around $500 in our config back then), but they’ve all been replaced with laptops now.

                In my department we run around with $3000 MacBook Pros, so not very budget minded at all.

      • @fatalError
        link
        19 months ago

        Not sure where you’re from. But here is a random one from ebay . You will find many like it. I got this model with 4gb ram, 256 ssd and power supply for ~80€ on europe, much less then I could pay for any PI4 at the time that came with no case, no psu, no ssd. It idles around 3-4w headless with no peripherals running home assistant. There are other models too ofc. Just have a look around used hardware stores if you have them around your area.