NetBSD seems to be thriving of late: as the Linux world goes pro-AI, some of the AI-averse are turning to this explicitly AI-free project.

The NetBSD project’s Mastodon feed reports that it received a record 120 donations last month, and it has far exceeded its target:

“We received $120,282 USD in total. Naturally, this has completely filled up our donations target bar which was set at $50,000. Time to fund some projects!”

It’s a welcome contrast to the usual stories of under-funded FOSS projects, and it follows a visible uptick in people asking about NetBSD in the FOSS Unix groups we read, ever since Emperor Penguin Torvalds said that Linux was not an anti-AI project back in July, and the following month, the Debian project polled its developers on AI use, and they chose to permit AI-generated contributions.

  • kaidenshi
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    2 hours ago

    This is my experience over the past 10+ years of dabbling with the BSDs; also see my website for example installations of OpenBSD and FreeBSD (currently working on a NetBSD article).

    OpenBSD is the easiest to learn from scratch, and its installer is simple and takes less than 10 minutes even on older hardware. It has by far the best documentation of the three big BSDs. Out of the box it’s extremely barebones (a feature, not a bug, and shared by all three major BSDs). If you select to run X11 during installation you get FVWM2, not the prettiest but functional. You can get to a nice Xfce or even GNOME (if that’s your thing) desktop using packages in the repository. If you have AMD and/or Intel GPUs, you’ll have accelerated video, and compositing if your desktop/wm has that feature. There’s also xcompmgr and picom available. If you have an Nvidia GPU, OpenBSD won’t work with it. Overall, it’s very usable as a modern desktop workstation, with the caveat that it’s slower than the other BSDs in everyday use. This is partly due to security mitigations being turned up to 11 which can be dialed back down, and partly due to the developers prioritizing security and correctness over raw performance. Still, it’s good enough for a daily driver for many folks. Also LibreWolf is now in ports thanks to the much appreciated efforts of Leah Rowe (of LibreBoot fame).

    FreeBSD is far more performant than the others, especially on the desktop, and has the largest development community behind it. It also has somewhat broader hardware support than the others, though OpenBSD actually has better Wi-Fi drivers for some cards. FreeBSD isn’t quite as easy to get up to a functioning desktop, but they are working on a “desktop installer” script to make it easier. Still, nothing a seasoned Linux veteran can’t handle with a little help from the docs. It’s blazing fast on the desktop, has good KDE Plasma support now, and has the fastest and most robust file system in ZFS. Still, bear in mind that to this day most FreeBSD devs don’t dogfood the OS (they do their development on macOS or Linux workstations rather than FreeBSD natively).

    I’m not as familiar with NetBSD, only having dabbled with it on a Raspberry Pi and a couple of older PCs in the past few years (and my Sega Dreamcast in the early 2000s), but so far it seems to be kind of a middle ground between the other two. Performance is right in the middle, easier to install (with a CTWM desktop by default) than FreeBSD, and hardware support is kind of all over the place. A bonus is the broad spectrum of platform support; you have the usual AMD64/ARM/ARM64 giants, but also tons of smaller, older, and more esoteric platforms. My only real gripe is no LibreWolf; we’re stuck with a rolling release of Firefox that is a bit buggy at times. I believe it has the smallest development team of the three as well as the least amount of funding, but as the article said they have had a boost in interest and funding since coming out as anti-“AI” and I hope that affords them the resources needed to advance the project in all areas.

    EDIT: too many thinking bears