The new law that bans gender-affirming care for minors also mandates that adult patients seeking trans health care sign an informed consent form. It also requires a physician to oversee any health care related to transitioning, and for people to see that doctor in person. Those rules have proven particularly onerous because many people received care from nurse practitioners and used telehealth. The law also made it a crime to violate the new requirements.
Another new law that allows doctors and pharmacists to refuse to treat transgender people further limits their options.
I don’t know how liberal lemmy is compared to reddit, so I’ll dare state my opinion, which I don’t think is extremist.
I don’t feel comfortable allowing everyone to transition. I’m not religious, I’m just from a time and place (ie not the West) where this was considered worrying and individuals who battled this got the help they needed to feel comfortable in their bodies instead of butchering them and feeding them questionable drugs. It was seen as a symptom of a different problem, a societal one, a problem with one’s surroundings and influences rather than a weird bug in their brain.
I for one still believe that narrative. I don’t hate the individuals, as I have many queer/trans/whatever-you-call-them-with-one-word contacts, but I’m disappointed that the system allows them to suffer and helps manifest their mental problems into a physical form, rather than treating the root cause of whatever in their life is causing their inability to accept that they have one soul and one body and they have to get them to work together to live a prosperous life.
The fact that this is being normalized now tells me that large parts of our society have been laden with whatever this disease is. That reality can be manipulated, that with enough excuses, we can get everyone to pretend some things are real.
Of course, punishing the individual like these laws are doing isn’t the right thing to do, but the establishment has rarely prioritized the working man and his struggles.
Modern psychiatric science has determined that, for many people who do not feel comfortable in their assigned birth gender, transitioning is the most mentally healthy thing to do.
It is literally stopping suicides. When you let an adolescent transition, their risk of suicide drops 73%.
Here’s the problem- you want them to feel comfortable in their own bodies. They don’t and never will. Same with people who get nose jobs or breast augmentation or any other form of plastic surgery. And plenty of trans people never even have surgery. They can “detransition” any time they like.
As for why it’s “normalized?” Maybe because people are more compassionate than you are these days?
Oh, wonderful to hear! Good thing it’s not up to you.
Very constructive. That’ll show me!
What is the end goal of this reply? You aren’t getting upvotes because this isn’t reddit, you’re not broadening my horizons with the hostility. Why bother posting in the first place if all you can do is feign niceness while still managing to be a dick?
They have 22 upvotes, you have 3. You are simply incorrect.
That’s a lot of flowery words for “I’m a bigot.”
Short version: you get the squicks and are uncomfy because someone else is getting medical care that is none of your fucking business, so you’re fine with shitting on the rights of fellow human beings.
How enlightened of you.
That is an awfully long winded way of saying you can’t mind your own business.
The treatment you’re talking about is conversion therapy - largely considered torture by modern standards. And what happened to the people who received that “treatment?” Statistically they probably fucking killed themselves. Which, like, I guess does solve the issue of you being uncomfortable around trans people and having to see us in public.
I’m not sure if you’re a ghoul or woefully uninformed. I’d suggest reading the medical literature on trans people. Nearly every psychiatric and pediatric organization of note agrees that supporting their transition leads to better healthcare outcomes for trans people by a pretty large margin. This isn’t some kind of social contagion or whatever the fuck you’re talking about. This is evidenced medical practice.
That’s not how beings trans works, and you should consider asking more of them and doctors what they think should be done instead.
But, I think you know that, or you wouldn’t be using the same language as transphobes.
“same language as transphobes”
I can’t use English now? Of course you’re welcome to label my opinion as whatever you’d like, I just don’t agree that this is transphobia.
Using the word butchering to describe gender-affirmation surgery is transphobic language. You wouldn’t use it to describe breast reduction surgery or facial reconstructive surgery, so you are, in fact, using transphobic dogwhistles.