Passkeys as password replacements reduce the total factors required to login to a service. If you use 2fa for all your services anyway then passkeys are a downgrade. That’s why so many people are angry they are having security options removed.

For people who use the same username and password everywhere, then passkeys are a upgrade.

So normal people get a benefit from passkeys in exchange for getting locked into a ecosystem.

For security minded people I hate passkeys.

• Less factors to login
• Discoverable
• • Unlike fido2 webauthn the service the credentials attach to have to be known, so if anyone steals your hardware key, or gets access to your phone they can see all the passkeys and accounts you have

I WANT my logins to be something I know, something I have, and something I am. Password, hardware key, biometric unlock of key.

I don’t mind passkeys existing, but I HATE that services are replacing hardware key flows with passkey flows. I want to use my hardware key as fido2 not as a passkey. I don’t want to downgrade my security! Microsoft makes it impossible to use a 2fa hardware key as a second factor now, only as a passkey, that’s strictly worse then before.