German trans cryptographer who lives in the Netherlands and wants to be Dutch.

https://blahaj.zone/@Fiona

https://fiona.onl/

  • 2 Posts
  • 83 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 5th, 2024

help-circle
  • Someone feeling unsafe or uncomfortable is not sufficient evidence to claim that someone isn’t inclusive. For that you need to present concrete evidence of a consistent pattern of behaviors that are of some degree of seriousness.

    And while I have minor criticism of the moderation (mostly w.r.t. some servers not being blocked, when they should be, though this seems more like an oversight than intention), I have always found Ada to be very responsive, fair, and understanding, when I sent her a DM about an issue.

    Now, you are of course free to disagree and to dislike her moderation-policies, in which case you are free to change servers. This is fedi, so there is nothing stopping you from staying in contact with your friends or even hang out in Lemmy communities here. The primary reason to choose a Fedi server is the moderation team and if you don’t like it, that’s okay, choose another one.

    That said, you give of the vibes of one of those extremely self-centered people that have been known to destroy progressive spaces by abusing progressive or therapy-language to make everyone miserable. I don’t know you well enough to want to judge you on that (because I try to make those decisions based on evidence, not based on feelings, as you want us to do in your criticism of the mods), but you may want to reflect on that…





  • Fiona@lemmy.blahaj.zoneto196@lemmy.blahaj.zone•difficulty rule
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    3 months ago

    The thing is: We are not doing that on any other skill-based competitive thing (sports or similar), even though you could largely make the same argument there. Of course any game like this will want to be respectful to its most dedicated players instead of pissing them off.

    Honestly, wanting to insult the best players mostly just comes across salty, as if by someone who is annoyed that they are not particularly good (which is fine) and mad about it (which indicates that YOU are the one taking this too seriously). Back in the day playing through the Maw on Legendary in Halo CE was something that was respect if you managed to do it, but nobody really looked down on others for not doing so…



  • Okay, there is a lot to unpack here, and I kinda wanted to buy groceries now, so I’ll make it quick.

    but I was under the impression that which treatment a trans person needed was not reliably the one for a particular sex. That is to say, depending on what was troubling you, you might need either the male or the female version, or potentially even a secret third thing.

    Yes, I was speaking generally about general tendencies in the simple case of binary trans people going through the typical “full” program. There are a lot of nuances, especially among nonbinary people, where this becomes more murky. But it’s worth noting that the same holds for binary cis people, things are far from simple there either: As I wrote, sex is a bimodal distribution and if you assign people to the peak they are closer to, what I wrote will be a reasonable first approximation.

    That said, I wouldn’t consider that to be what makes you a woman.

    That is a fair approach, I recently understood that I have kinda always rejected the notion of social gender roles on a pretty fundamental level, making it far more about outward biological characteristics more relevant.

    So: “Yes, but…”

    To me, “biological woman” is like “biological fish”; there is no set of biological characteristics that can determine with 100% accuracy whether a given animal fits into that group.

    Yes. you always have a grey zone, but that notably doesn’t invalidate the concept of a fish, it just means that we have to be aware that not everything fits perfectly.


  • And we are losing.

    No, we are not! Don’t let the shitty trends in some places get to you, don’t take the black pill. Even if it may take some time, culture is moving in our favor. You can nowadays just be an out and proud trans person, and live a pretty normal live. That would have been almost unthinkable 20 years ago. Everyone has at least some idea of what trans people are, and you basically cannot be a broadly respected person, especially within educated and urban circles, if you are hateful. Kids nowadays have early access to information of what it means to be trans and role-models.

    Yes, there are setbacks, losses, pain, and many lost battles. But there is no way for them to win this war. After all is said and done victory for us may take time but is ultimately inevitable. Don’t loose sight of that and don’t loose hope!


  • Oh, those terms exist and can even have reasonable meaning, just not the one the transphobes think they do:

    I am a biological woman: My metabolism runs on estrogen, my T is basically nothing, I have breasts and at some point in the future I’ll even have a vagina. If I am to receive sex-dependent medical treatment I have to receive the female version, because that is just how my body works now.

    What I’m saying is that the term can be useful in certain contexts, but the dividing line is not cis/trans but if anything what someone’s hormones are doing, assuming that it even aligns with what is typical for one of the two peaks in a bimodal distribution (meaning that there are very much people who can easily be classified as “neither”).

    But unless you are a biologist or directly engaging in medical treatment or research, it is just not a relevant thing.







  • Ganz ehrlich: Ich finde den Artikel und die darin zitierten Kommentare ziemlich daneben: Das sie in der Vergangenheit im NSU war schließt nicht aus, dass sie ihre Meinung tatsächlich geändert hat und das einfach nur auf Basis der Verurteilung zu verneinen ist nicht okay, so lange es dazu keine weiteren konkreten Indizien gibt, die aber weder hier noch dort genannt werden.

    Ich sage nicht, dass sie definitiv einen Sinneswandel hatte, ich sage, dass niemand hier wissen kann ob dem so ist, und dass es echt nicht okay ist, sich jetzt darüber zu beschweren, dass sie in ein Aussteigerprogramm aufgenommen wurde. Das ist ja noch nicht einmal irgendetwas, dass ihr direkt etwas bringt, außer dass es sie vielleicht tatsächlich in die Richtung leiten könnte, was, zur Erinnerung an alle, in einem Rechtsstaat der Hauptzweck der Strafe ist: Die Resozialisierung der Täter!

    Das wird gerne vergessen, aber die Wiedereingliederung von Verbrechern ist das primäre Ziel von Strafen in einem Rechtsstaat!

    Und ob dass das ist, was hier passiert müssen Gutachter und Gerichte, nicht Opferangehörige, Journalisten und Nutzer von sozialen Medien entscheiden!